Literature DB >> 21644945

Eight criticisms not to make about group selection.

Omar Tonsi Eldakar1, David Sloan Wilson.   

Abstract

Group selection, which was once widely rejected as a significant evolutionary force, is now accepted by all who seriously study the subject. There is still widespread confusion about group selection, however, not only among students and the general public, but among professional evolutionists who do not directly study the subject. We list eight criticisms that are frequently invoked against group selection, which can be permanently laid to rest based upon current knowledge. Experts will always find something to critique about group selection, as for any important subject, but these eight criticisms are not among them. Laying them to rest will enable authors to openly use the term group selection without being handicapped during the review process.
© 2011 The Author(s). Evolution© 2011 The Society for the Study of Evolution.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2011        PMID: 21644945      PMCID: PMC3110649          DOI: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2011.01290.x

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Evolution        ISSN: 0014-3820            Impact factor:   3.694


  14 in total

1.  Local migration promotes competitive restraint in a host-pathogen 'tragedy of the commons'.

Authors:  Benjamin Kerr; Claudia Neuhauser; Brendan J M Bohannan; Antony M Dean
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2006-07-06       Impact factor: 49.962

Review 2.  Rethinking the theoretical foundation of sociobiology.

Authors:  David Sloan Wilson; Edward O Wilson
Journal:  Q Rev Biol       Date:  2007-12       Impact factor: 4.875

3.  Darwin 200: The needs of the many.

Authors:  Marek Kohn
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2008-11-20       Impact factor: 49.962

4.  A mechanism for the evolution of altruism among nonkin: positive assortment through environmental feedback.

Authors:  John W Pepper; Barbara B Smuts
Journal:  Am Nat       Date:  2002-08       Impact factor: 3.926

5.  Experimental studies of group selection: what do they tell us about group selection in nature?

Authors:  C J Goodnight; L Stevens
Journal:  Am Nat       Date:  1997-07       Impact factor: 3.926

Review 6.  Did Darwin write the Origin backwards?

Authors:  Elliott Sober
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2009-06-15       Impact factor: 11.205

7.  Population structure mediates sexual conflict in water striders.

Authors:  Omar Tonsi Eldakar; Michael J Dlugos; John W Pepper; David Sloan Wilson
Journal:  Science       Date:  2009-11-06       Impact factor: 47.728

8.  Multilevel selection, cooperation, and altruism : Reflections on unto others: The evolution and psychology of unselfish behavior.

Authors:  B Smuts
Journal:  Hum Nat       Date:  1999-09

9.  Selection and covariance.

Authors:  G R Price
Journal:  Nature       Date:  1970-08-01       Impact factor: 49.962

10.  The role of multilevel selection in the evolution of sexual conflict in the water strider aquarius remigis.

Authors:  Omar Tonsi Eldakar; David Sloan Wilson; Michael J Dlugos; John W Pepper
Journal:  Evolution       Date:  2010-11       Impact factor: 3.694

View more
  11 in total

1.  Questioning evidence of group selection in spiders.

Authors:  Lena Grinsted; Trine Bilde; James D J Gilbert
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2015-08-27       Impact factor: 49.962

2.  Pruitt & Goodnight reply.

Authors:  Jonathan N Pruitt; Charles J Goodnight
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2015-08-27       Impact factor: 49.962

3.  Availability of public goods shapes the evolution of competing metabolic strategies.

Authors:  Herwig Bachmann; Martin Fischlechner; Iraes Rabbers; Nakul Barfa; Filipe Branco dos Santos; Douwe Molenaar; Bas Teusink
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2013-08-12       Impact factor: 11.205

4.  Faith, Fact, and Behaviorism.

Authors:  J E R Staddon
Journal:  Behav Anal       Date:  2013

Review 5.  Evolution, epigenetics and cooperation.

Authors:  Patrick Bateson
Journal:  J Biosci       Date:  2014-04       Impact factor: 1.826

Review 6.  Cellular differentiation and individuality in the 'minor' multicellular taxa.

Authors:  Matthew D Herron; Armin Rashidi; Deborah E Shelton; William W Driscoll
Journal:  Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc       Date:  2013-03-01

7.  Edward o. Wilson and the organicist tradition.

Authors:  Abraham H Gibson
Journal:  J Hist Biol       Date:  2013       Impact factor: 1.326

8.  Hypotheses for the Evolution of Reduced Reactive Aggression in the Context of Human Self-Domestication.

Authors:  Richard W Wrangham
Journal:  Front Psychol       Date:  2019-08-20

9.  The role of D4 receptor gene exon III polymorphisms in shaping human altruism and prosocial behavior.

Authors:  Yushi Jiang; Soo H Chew; Richard P Ebstein
Journal:  Front Hum Neurosci       Date:  2013-05-14       Impact factor: 3.169

10.  Dopamine D4 receptor gene and religious affiliation correlate with dictator game altruism in males and not females: evidence for gender-sensitive gene × culture interaction.

Authors:  Yushi Jiang; Rachel Bachner-Melman; Soo Hong Chew; Richard P Ebstein
Journal:  Front Neurosci       Date:  2015-09-24       Impact factor: 4.677

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.