Literature DB >> 21245477

Gametes or organs? How should we legally classify ovaries used for transplantation in the USA?

Lisa Campo-Engelstein1.   

Abstract

Ovarian tissue transplantation is an experimental procedure that can be used to treat both infertility and premature menopause. Working within the current legal framework in the USA, I examine whether ovarian tissue should be legally treated like gametes or organs in the case of ovarian tissue transplantation between two women. One option is to base classification upon its intended use: ovarian tissue used to treat infertility would be classified like gametes, and ovarian tissue used to treat premature menopause would be classified like organs. In the end, however, I argue that this approach will not work because it engenders too many legal, cultural and logistical concerns and that, at least for the near future, we should treat ovarian tissue like gametes.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2011        PMID: 21245477      PMCID: PMC3103707          DOI: 10.1136/jme.2010.038588

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Med Ethics        ISSN: 0306-6800            Impact factor:   2.903


  31 in total

1.  Outcome of pregnancy in renal allograft recipients: SIUT experience.

Authors:  R Naqvi; H Noor; S Ambareen; H Khan; A Haider; N Jafri; A Alam; R Aziz; K Manzoor; T Aziz; E Ahmed; F Akhtar; A Naqvi; A Rizvi
Journal:  Transplant Proc       Date:  2006-09       Impact factor: 1.066

2.  Allograft of ovarian cortex between two genetically non-identical sisters: case report.

Authors:  J Donnez; M M Dolmans; C Pirard; A Van Langendonckt; D Demylle; P Jadoul; J Squifflet
Journal:  Hum Reprod       Date:  2007-08-01       Impact factor: 6.918

Review 3.  Ovarian tissue and oocyte cryopreservation.

Authors: 
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  2006-11       Impact factor: 7.329

4.  Facial allograft transplantation, personal identity and subjectivity.

Authors:  J S Swindell
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2007-08       Impact factor: 2.903

5.  Moving the womb.

Authors:  Arthur L Caplan; Constance Perry; Lauren A Plante; Joseph Saloma; Frances R Batzer
Journal:  Hastings Cent Rep       Date:  2007 May-Jun       Impact factor: 2.683

6.  A series of monozygotic twins discordant for ovarian failure: ovary transplantation (cortical versus microvascular) and cryopreservation.

Authors:  S J Silber; M DeRosa; J Pineda; K Lenahan; D Grenia; K Gorman; R G Gosden
Journal:  Hum Reprod       Date:  2008-02-18       Impact factor: 6.918

7.  ACOG Committee Opinion No. 405: ovarian tissue and oocyte cryopreservation.

Authors: 
Journal:  Obstet Gynecol       Date:  2008-05       Impact factor: 7.661

8.  State laws and regulations addressing third-party reimbursement for infertility treatment: implications for cancer survivors.

Authors:  Gwendolyn P Quinn; Susan T Vadaparampil; Kerri McGowan Lowrey; Shelby Eidson; Caprice Knapp; Orhan Bukulmez
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  2010-06-23       Impact factor: 7.329

Review 9.  Premature ovarian failure is not premature menopause.

Authors:  S N Kalantaridou; L M Nelson
Journal:  Ann N Y Acad Sci       Date:  2000       Impact factor: 5.691

10.  American Society of Clinical Oncology recommendations on fertility preservation in cancer patients.

Authors:  Stephanie J Lee; Leslie R Schover; Ann H Partridge; Pasquale Patrizio; W Hamish Wallace; Karen Hagerty; Lindsay N Beck; Lawrence V Brennan; Kutluk Oktay
Journal:  J Clin Oncol       Date:  2006-05-01       Impact factor: 44.544

View more
  4 in total

1.  Fertility Preservation for Prepubertal Girls: Update and Current Challenges.

Authors:  Nina Resetkova; Masanori Hayashi; Lisa A Kolp; Mindy S Christianson
Journal:  Curr Obstet Gynecol Rep       Date:  2013-12-01

Review 2.  Oncofertility: a grand collaboration between reproductive medicine and oncology.

Authors:  Teresa K Woodruff
Journal:  Reproduction       Date:  2015-06-30       Impact factor: 3.906

3.  Fresh and cryopreserved ovarian tissue from deceased young donors yields viable follicles.

Authors:  Yuting Fan; Colleen L Flanagan; Margaret A Brunette; Andrea S Jones; Brendon M Baker; Sherman J Silber; Ariella Shikanov
Journal:  F S Sci       Date:  2021-06-10

4.  The Ethics of Fertility Preservation for Pediatric Patients With Differences (Disorders) of Sex Development.

Authors:  Lisa Campo-Engelstein; Diane Chen; Arlene B Baratz; Emilie K Johnson; Courtney Finlayson
Journal:  J Endocr Soc       Date:  2017-06-01
  4 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.