Ali Johnson1, Judy R Rees, Molly Schwenn, Bruce Riddle, Castine Verrill, Maria O Celaya, Dawn A Nicolaides, Sai Cherala, Melanie Feinberg, Ann Gray, Lisa Rutstein, Matthew S Katz, Johannes C Nunnink. 1. Vermont Cancer Registry, Vermont Department of Health; Fletcher Allen Health Care, Burlington; Vermont Center for Cancer Medicine, St Albans, VT; New Hampshire State Cancer Registry; Department of Community and Family Medicine, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover; Office of Health Statistics and Data Management, New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services, Concord; Northern New England Clinical Oncology Society, Sandown; Radiation Oncology Associates, Manchester, NH; Maine Medical Center; Maine Surgical Care Group, Maine Cancer Consortium, Portland; and Maine Cancer Registry, Maine Centers for Disease Control, Department of Health and Human Services, Augusta, ME.
Abstract
PURPOSE: A team from Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont evaluated quality of care for breast and colon cancers in these predominantly rural states. METHODS: Central cancer registry records from diagnosis years 2003 to 2004 in Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont were aggregated. Patient residence was classified into three tiers (small rural, large rural, and urban) using Rural-Urban Commuting Area classification. RESULTS: Among 6,134 women diagnosed with breast cancer, there were significant differences between rural and urban residents in age (P < .001), stage (P < .001), and tumor size (P = .006). Use of breast-conserving surgery was similar, but sentinel lymph node (SLN) dissection was more common in urban (44.1%) than in large rural (39.9%) and small rural (37.6%) areas. Patients who underwent SLN dissection were more likely to receive radiation therapy after lumpectomy than patients who underwent regional lymph node dissection without SLN (85.9% v 75.5%). However, there was no statistically significant association between the rates of postlumpectomy radiation therapy by residence. Among 2,848 patients with colon cancer, patient characteristics in rural and urban areas were similar, but there were differences in their subsequent surgical treatment (P < .001) and lymph node sampling (P = .079). Adjuvant chemotherapy for patients with stage III colon cancer was less frequent in rural (57.3%) than in urban areas (64.7%; P < .001). CONCLUSION: Central cancer registry data, aggregated among three states, identified differences between rural and urban areas in care for patients with breast and colon cancers. To our knowledge, this is the first time residential category, cancer stage, and treatment data have been analyzed for multiple states using population-based data.
PURPOSE: A team from Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont evaluated quality of care for breast and colon cancers in these predominantly rural states. METHODS: Central cancer registry records from diagnosis years 2003 to 2004 in Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont were aggregated. Patient residence was classified into three tiers (small rural, large rural, and urban) using Rural-Urban Commuting Area classification. RESULTS: Among 6,134 women diagnosed with breast cancer, there were significant differences between rural and urban residents in age (P < .001), stage (P < .001), and tumor size (P = .006). Use of breast-conserving surgery was similar, but sentinel lymph node (SLN) dissection was more common in urban (44.1%) than in large rural (39.9%) and small rural (37.6%) areas. Patients who underwent SLN dissection were more likely to receive radiation therapy after lumpectomy than patients who underwent regional lymph node dissection without SLN (85.9% v 75.5%). However, there was no statistically significant association between the rates of postlumpectomy radiation therapy by residence. Among 2,848 patients with colon cancer, patient characteristics in rural and urban areas were similar, but there were differences in their subsequent surgical treatment (P < .001) and lymph node sampling (P = .079). Adjuvant chemotherapy for patients with stage III colon cancer was less frequent in rural (57.3%) than in urban areas (64.7%; P < .001). CONCLUSION: Central cancer registry data, aggregated among three states, identified differences between rural and urban areas in care for patients with breast and colon cancers. To our knowledge, this is the first time residential category, cancer stage, and treatment data have been analyzed for multiple states using population-based data.
Authors: B Fisher; J Dignam; N Wolmark; E Mamounas; J Costantino; W Poller; E R Fisher; D L Wickerham; M Deutsch; R Margolese; N Dimitrov; M Kavanah Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 1998-02 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: C C Compton; L P Fielding; L J Burgart; B Conley; H S Cooper; S R Hamilton; M E Hammond; D E Henson; R V Hutter; R B Nagle; M L Nielsen; D J Sargent; C R Taylor; M Welton; C Willett Journal: Arch Pathol Lab Med Date: 2000-07 Impact factor: 5.534
Authors: Al B Benson; Deborah Schrag; Mark R Somerfield; Alfred M Cohen; Alvaro T Figueredo; Patrick J Flynn; Monika K Krzyzanowska; Jean Maroun; Pamela McAllister; Eric Van Cutsem; Melissa Brouwers; Manya Charette; Daniel G Haller Journal: J Clin Oncol Date: 2004-06-15 Impact factor: 44.544
Authors: Giovanni Li Destri; Antonio Salvatore Rubino; Rosalia Latino; Fabio Giannone; Raffaele Lanteri; Beniamino Scilletta; Antonio Di Cataldo Journal: Int Surg Date: 2015-04
Authors: Ali Johnson; Leanne Shulman; Jennifer Kachajian; Brian L Sprague; Farrah Khan; Ted James; David Cranmer; Peter Young; Ruth Heimann Journal: J Oncol Pract Date: 2016-08-30 Impact factor: 3.840