BACKGROUND:Mechanical debridement of fibrin and/or necrosis promotes healing of arterial and venous leg ulcers but is limited by pain associated with the procedure. OBJECTIVE: The main objective of this study was to compare the respective analgesic effect of nitrous oxide oxygen mixture (NOOM) inhalation and lidocaïne-prilocaïne cream (LPC) application during the mechanical repeated debridement of chronic arterial and venous leg ulcers. METHODS: In this randomized, multicentre, open-label study, pain was evaluated before and after each care and debridement session using a Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and a Verbal Rating Scale (VRS), in the context of usual debridement and wound care process. The Quality of debridement and tolerability of the treatments were also assessed. RESULTS: Forty-one patients were randomized: 20 received NOOM and 21 LPC. Pain assessed by VAS and VRS was more intense in the NOOM group than in the LPC group (5.29 vs. 3.68 and 2.87 vs. 1.71, P<0.001, for the two scales respectively). No differences were found concerning quality of debridement, safety or tolerability between the two groups. CONCLUSION: This pilot study demonstrates the superiority of the LPC over NOOM for pain control during the mechanical debridement of chronic leg ulcers.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Mechanical debridement of fibrin and/or necrosis promotes healing of arterial and venous leg ulcers but is limited by pain associated with the procedure. OBJECTIVE: The main objective of this study was to compare the respective analgesic effect of nitrous oxide oxygen mixture (NOOM) inhalation and lidocaïne-prilocaïne cream (LPC) application during the mechanical repeated debridement of chronic arterial and venous leg ulcers. METHODS: In this randomized, multicentre, open-label study, pain was evaluated before and after each care and debridement session using a Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and a Verbal Rating Scale (VRS), in the context of usual debridement and wound care process. The Quality of debridement and tolerability of the treatments were also assessed. RESULTS: Forty-one patients were randomized: 20 received NOOM and 21 LPC. Pain assessed by VAS and VRS was more intense in the NOOM group than in the LPC group (5.29 vs. 3.68 and 2.87 vs. 1.71, P<0.001, for the two scales respectively). No differences were found concerning quality of debridement, safety or tolerability between the two groups. CONCLUSION: This pilot study demonstrates the superiority of the LPC over NOOM for pain control during the mechanical debridement of chronic leg ulcers.
Authors: Maria G Onesti; Paolo Fioramonti; Pasquale Fino; Diego Massera; Vittoria Amorosi; Nicolo Scuderi Journal: Int Wound J Date: 2012-10-29 Impact factor: 3.315