Differential HMG-CoA lyase expression in human tissues provides clues about 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria.

3-Hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria is a rare human autosomal recessive disorder caused by deficiency of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl CoA lyase (HL). This mitochondrial enzyme catalyzes the common final step of leucine degradation and ketogenesis. Acute symptoms include vomiting, seizures and lethargy, accompanied by metabolic acidosis and hypoketotic hypoglycaemia. Such organs as the liver, brain, pancreas, and heart can also be involved. However, the pathophysiology of this disease is only partially understood. We measured mRNA levels, protein expression and enzyme activity of human HMG-CoA lyase from liver, kidney, pancreas, testis, heart, skeletal muscle, and brain. Surprisingly, the pancreas is, after the liver, the tissue with most HL activity. However, in heart and adult brain, HL activity was not detected in the mitochondrial fraction. These findings contribute to our understanding of the enzyme function and the consequences of its deficiency and suggest the need for assessment of pancreatic damage in these patients.

Introduction

3-Hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria (MIM 246450) is a rare human autosomal recessive disorder caused by deficiency of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl CoA lyase (HMG-CoA lyase, HL, EC 4.1.3.4) (Faull et al. 1976). This mitochondrial enzyme catalyzes the cleavage of HMG-CoA to form acetyl-CoA and acetoacetate, which is the common final step in leucine degradation and ketogenesis.

The disease usually appears in the first year of life after a fasting period or during intercurrent illness. Acute symptoms include vomiting, seizures and lethargy, accompanied by metabolic acidosis, hypoketotic hypoglycaemia and a characteristic pattern of elevated urinary organic acid metabolites (Gibson et al. 1988; Schutgens et al. 1979; Wysocki and Hahnel 1986). Such organs as the liver and brain are frequently affected, and occasionally the pancreas and heart can also be involved (Gibson et al. 1994; Leung et al. 2009; Muroi et al. 2000; Urganci et al. 2001; Wilson et al. 1984; Zafeiriou et al. 2007; Zoghbi et al. 1986).

The pathophysiology of this disease is only partially understood. It may be explained by the deficit of an alternative energy source (ketone bodies), the intracellular accumulation of toxic organic acids or fatty acids or secondary carnitine deficiency (Kahler et al. 1994; Mitchell et al. 1995; Leung et al. 2009). However, these interpretations were not based on a thorough understanding of the expression or activity of HL in the affected tissues. To our knowledge, HL has been examined only in liver, leukocytes and fibroblasts (Ashmarina et al. 1994; Wysocki and Hahnel 1976a; Wysocki and Hahnel 1976b) but not in other human tissues. This report is the first study of mRNA levels, protein expression and enzyme activity of human HMG-CoA lyase in kidney, pancreas, testis, heart, skeletal muscle, and brain. The results may improve our understanding of the enzyme function and the involvement of these organs in 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria.

Materials and methods

HL mRNA

HL mRNA was measured in Multiple Tissue cDNA (MTC) panels (Clontech) by a Real-Time quantitative PCR method using a TaqMan Gene Expression Assay (Assay HMGCL:Hs00609306_m1 Assay GAPDH:Hs99999905_m1) (Applied Biosystems). The levels of HL mRNA was calculated relative to the GAPDH control by the ΔΔCt method. The level of expression HL in skeletal muscle was arbitrarily taken as the calibrator to normalize the other tissues.

HL protein analysis

Human tissues: liver, kidney, pancreas, testis, heart, skeletal muscle, and brain were obtained within 10–12 h post mortem at autopsy from two male subjects at the Department of Pathology of our University. They were 65 and 70 years old, and representative samples of organs of approximately 1–2 g were taken from each subject. To minimize protein degradation, the bodies were kept at 4°C until autopsy and all the tissues were immediately shock-frozen in N2 and stored at −80°C until use.

To isolate the mitochondrial fraction from human tissues, we performed subcellular separation as described by Clinkenbeard et al. (1975). Mitochondrial proteins separated on a 15% SDS-PAGE were transferred to a 0.45-μM nitrocellulose membrane by transfer blot. The membranes were probed with a mouse monoclonal antibody against HL (Abnova) (1:1,000 dilution) and revealed with the kit SuperSignal West Dura Extended Duration substrate (Thermo Scientific) using a peroxidase-conjugated secondary anti-mouse antibody (Sigma, 1:1,000). The protein bands were quantified using Scion ImageJ v1.39u software (Scion) and normalized to micrograms of total protein obtained from 10 mg of tissue. The density of the band corresponding to the liver was taken as 100%.

HL activity

After subcellular separation, 20 μl of mitochondrial fraction of different tissues (about 200 μg of protein) was used to measure enzymatic activity. HMG–CoA lyase activity was assayed by the spectrophotometric assay described by Wanders et al. (1988), which measures the amounts of acetoacetate produced. The level of activity was expressed as mU/g wet weight tissue (one milliunit equals 1 nmol of substrate converted/min).

PAP measurements

Serum samples were collected in acute and inter-crisis periods from 15 patients with 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria and stored at −20°C. All patients were diagnosed biochemically, and most of them were also diagnosed genetically (Table 1). Human serum PAP (pancreatitis associated protein) concentration was determined in control and patients by a kit based on a sandwich immunoenzymatic system (PancrePAP, Dynabio).

Table 1

Diagnostic parameters and pancreatitis associated protein (PAP) measurements in patients with 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria

Case	Organic acids	HMGCL mutation	PAP (ng/mL)	Reference
P1	+	c.109G>T	6.72	Casale et al. 1998
P2	+	c.109G>T	8.49	Casale et al. 1998
P3	+	c.109G>T/c504_5delCT	20.12a	Menao et al. 2009
			31.87
P4	+	c.144G>T/c.504_5delCT	5.61	Menao et al. 2009
P5	+	c.202_207delCT	9.42	Menao et al. 2009
P6	+	c.575T>C	6.17	Menao et al. 2009
P7	+	c.109G>T	5.39	Menao et al. 2009
P8	+	c.109G>T	7.85	Menao et al. 2009
P9	+	c.109G>T/c.825C>G	5.80a	-----
			7.37
P10	+	c.109G>T	2.13a	Menao et al. 2009
P11	+	c.109G>T/c.504_5delCT	5.35a	-----
P12	+	c.242G>A	5.93a	-----
P13	+	-----	13.63	-----
P14	+	-----	26.92a	-----
			10.46
P15	+	-----	6.16	-----

PAP values in controls (17.46 ± 8.27 ng/ml, mean ± SD, n = 11)

+ Elevated organic acids (3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric, 3-methylglutaconic, 3-methylglutaric and 3-hydroxy-isovaleric); ----- no data; PAP values measured in periods intercrisis and

ain acute crisis. PAP values < 50 ng/mL are considered normal

Results

HL mRNA was detected in all the tissues studied, albeit in widely differing amounts. Tissues with the highest expression or controversial ketogenic capacity are reported in Fig.1a: [liver 112.2 arbitrary units (100%) pancreas 43.5 (39%), kidney 17.56 (16%), testis 26.81 (24%), heart 2.96 (2,6%), brain 2.26 (2%), and skeletal muscle 1 (0.89%)]. The highest protein levels were found in human liver (100%), followed by pancreas (89%), testis (60%), kidney (42%), and skeletal muscle (36%); a weak signal was detected in heart (2%) and brain (1.8%) (Fig 1b). The enzyme activity was measured in the mitochondrial fraction. The liver had the highest activity (128.86 mU/g of wet weight tissue, 100%), followed by pancreas (58.49 mU/g, 45%), kidney (42.48 mU/g, 33%), testis (20.23 mU/g, 16%), and skeletal muscle (12.6 mU/g, 9,7%). HL enzyme activity was not detected in heart or brain (Fig. 1c).

Fig 1

Comparative analysis of mRNA levels, protein expression and enzymatic activity of HMG-CoA lyase in different human tissues. a Relative levels of mRNA HL expression in human tissues were measured by the ∆∆CT method with GAPDH as control. The expression levels of mRNA HL in skeletal muscle were arbitrarily taken as the calibrator for all calculations, and all other tissues were normalized accordingly. The values given are the average of four meausures, two from each subject. b HL protein expression was measured in mitochondrial fraction from human tissues. Four tissue samples were measured, two from each subject. The image shows a representative immunoblot from HL in different tissues. c HL activity was measured in the mitochondrial fraction of human tissues spectrophotometrically. Data are presented as mean±SEM (n = 4). Four tissue samples were measured, two from each subject

The values of PAP in patients varied between 5.31–31.87 ng/mL (Table 1) within a normal range (<50 ng/mL) (Desjeux et al. 2002). Simultaneously, we also measured PAP protein in 11 normal subjects as controls, and no differences (range 6.12–32.61 ng/mL) were found.

Discussion

This is the first time that a complete study of mRNA, protein and enzymatic activity of HL has been reported in a broad range of human tissues. The findings on the expression level and enzymatic activity of HL in these tissues may help us to understand the pathophysiology of HL deficiency.

Our results show that the liver has the highest HL activity, followed by pancreas. Both organs showed high levels of mRNA, protein and HL enzyme activity. The liver is the organ most frequently affected in this deficiency, although involvement is usually mild, with elevated transaminases and hepatomegaly (Urganci et al. 2001; Wysocki and Hahnel 1986). Since the liver does not use ketone bodies as a source of energy (Robinson and Williamson 1980), its deficit is not the cause of the disease. However, ketogenesis is more active in the liver and the blockage of this pathway could result in an accumulation of toxic intermediate metabolites. Recently, Leipnitz et al. (2009) have demonstrated in vitro the oxidative stress caused in the liver by the accumulation of organic acids in this deficiency.

Pancreatitis is a potential complication in patients with organic acidemias, especially methylmalonic and isovaleric (Kahler et al. 1994) and less frequently in 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria (Muroi et al. 2000; Wilson et al. 1984). The presence of HL protein in pancreas has been reported (MacDonald et al. 2007), but here we demonstrate that the pancreas has the highest enzymatic activity after the liver. This finding indicates that the pancreas has a high ketogenic capacity and suggests that, if ketone bodies regulate the release of insulin (Biden and Taylor 1983; Malaisse et al. 1990; Rhodes et al. 1985), some of them could be produced in the pancreas. In contrast, ketone bodies do not seem to play an important role as energy source in this organ. The finding of higher enzymatic activity in pancreas indicates that it may be more susceptible to toxic accumulation of metabolites. This hypothesis has been proposed to explain the pathogenesis of other organic acidemias of leucine catabolism (Gut et al. 1995; Kahler et al. 1994). The possibility of a progressive deterioration of the pancreas, without evident clinical manifestations, led us to study the protein PAP in patients with 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria, in order to detect and prevent any possible pancreas damage. PAP is a more sensitive marker of pancreatitis than amylase, whose levels remain high even in absence of symptoms (Kemppainen et al. 1996). The serum studies from patients in different situations of crisis and between crises did not show pathologic elevations. However, the higher activity of HL enzyme and the severity of the complications support the need to monitor the pancreatic function in patients with HL deficiency.

This study shows that, at different levels of mRNA, protein and enzymatic activity, HL is not found in the mitochondria from human brain. The absence of lyase activity in brain mitochondria is consistent with results obtained by McGarry and Foster (1969) and Bachhawat et al. (1955) in rat but it disagrees with the results of Shah (1982). Ketogenic activity by astrocytes has been described (Auestad et al. 1991; Guzmán and Blázquez 2004), but Auestad et al. (1991) have demonstrated that acetoacetate is mainly formed in astrocytes by deacylation of acetoacetyl-CoA and not by the action of the mitochondrial HMG-CoA cycle. In conclusion, despite the difficulties of studying the human brain immediately after death to avoid protein degradation, HL activity in mitochondria from adult human brain, if present, would be minimal. We suggest that the neurological alterations,frequently associated with this deficiency, are related to hypoglycaemia and to the absence of the only alternative substrate to glucose for the brain ketone bodies. Concomitantly, our results show that the organic acids would not be produced in situ, although they could cross the blood–brain barrier of an immature brain (Wajner et al. 2004) and cause damage.

Dilated cardiomyopathy has been described in two patients with 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaric aciduria, one young male (Gibson et al. 1994) and one adult (Leung et al. 2009). In this last case, the authors suggest that the cardiomyopathy results from impaired ketogenesis, intracellular fatty acid accumulation and a secondary carnitine deficiency. However, we found very little HL in heart tissue, from which we conclude that it does not regulate the entry of fatty acids to the heart and thus prevent their accumulation. Therefore, our results do not support the hypothesis of local accumulation of organic acids as a cause of the cardiomyopathy. In HL deficiency, heart disease could be caused by the lack of an alternative energy substrate. The heart is a continuously active muscle which uses various energy substrates depending on their availability (Kodde et al. 2007). Although ketone bodies are not an indispensable substrate, the added L-carnitine deficiency, which is caused by the HL deficiency, could alter the transport of fatty acids to the mitochondria for oxidation and the coupling between glycolysis and glucose oxidation (Allard et al. 2006). L-carnitine supplementation has been recommended for patients with organic acidurias to allow the elimination of toxic acids (Chalmers et al. 1984), but it could also improve the heart function.

In HL deficiency, alterations in other organs such as kidney, testis and skeletal muscle have not been reported, although in our study the enzymatic activity in kidney was high or moderately high in testis and skeletal muscle. Surprisingly, in muscle, although the mRNA levels were very low, moderate HL activity was measured. Similar cases are reported in the literature (Lewin et al. 2001), which suggests that certain tissues may have a lower turnover of the HL protein versus an unstable mRNA. In testis, the low activity levels of HL compared with the high enzyme expression suggest that HL activity could be regulated after translation in this tissue. All these tissues use the ketone bodies as an alternative energy source, but they do not show strong dependence on them (Robinson and Williamson 1980). Moreover, they are less sensitive to the accumulation of toxic metabolites, in contrast to the brain (Wajner et al. 2004) or pancreas (Leung and Chan 2009).

The results reported here help us to understand the enzyme function and pathophysiology of the 3-hydroxy–3methylglutaric aciduria. We suggest that pancreatitis should be included as a possible complication to seek in patients with HL deficiency, especially during acute episodes. Moreover, the addition of nutritional factors, such as L-carnitine, can be essential to prevent the development of cardiomyopathy.