BACKGROUND: Hospital admissions for cirrhosis have been increasing in the United Kingdom, leading to increased pressure on intensive care (ICU) services. Outcome data for patients admitted to ICU are currently limited to transplant centre reports, with mortality rates exceeding 70%. These tertiary reports could fuel a negative bias when patients with cirrhosis are reviewed for ICU admission in secondary care. AIMS: To determine whether disease severity and mortality rates in non-transplant general ICU are less severe than those reported by tertiary datasets. METHODS: A prospective dual-centre non-transplant ICU study. Admissions were screened for cirrhosis and physiological and biochemical data were collected. Disease-specific and critical illness scoring systems were evaluated. RESULTS: Cirrhosis was present in 137/4198 (3.3%) of ICU admissions. ICU and hospital mortality were 38% and 47%, respectively; median age 50 [43-59] years, 68% men, 72% alcoholic cirrhosis, median Child Pugh Score (CPS) 10 [8-11], Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) 18 [12-24], Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score (APACHE II) 16 [13-22]. CONCLUSIONS: Mortality rates and disease staging were notably lower than in the published literature, suggesting that patients have a more favourable outlook than previously considered. Transplant centre data should therefore be interpreted with caution when evaluating the merits of intensive care admission for patients in general secondary care ICUs.
BACKGROUND: Hospital admissions for cirrhosis have been increasing in the United Kingdom, leading to increased pressure on intensive care (ICU) services. Outcome data for patients admitted to ICU are currently limited to transplant centre reports, with mortality rates exceeding 70%. These tertiary reports could fuel a negative bias when patients with cirrhosis are reviewed for ICU admission in secondary care. AIMS: To determine whether disease severity and mortality rates in non-transplant general ICU are less severe than those reported by tertiary datasets. METHODS: A prospective dual-centre non-transplant ICU study. Admissions were screened for cirrhosis and physiological and biochemical data were collected. Disease-specific and critical illness scoring systems were evaluated. RESULTS:Cirrhosis was present in 137/4198 (3.3%) of ICU admissions. ICU and hospital mortality were 38% and 47%, respectively; median age 50 [43-59] years, 68% men, 72% alcoholic cirrhosis, median Child Pugh Score (CPS) 10 [8-11], Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) 18 [12-24], Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score (APACHE II) 16 [13-22]. CONCLUSIONS: Mortality rates and disease staging were notably lower than in the published literature, suggesting that patients have a more favourable outlook than previously considered. Transplant centre data should therefore be interpreted with caution when evaluating the merits of intensive care admission for patients in general secondary care ICUs.
Authors: J Campbell; J McPeake; M Shaw; A Puxty; P Emerson; S J Thomson; T M Rahman; T Quasim; J Kinsella Journal: J Intensive Care Soc Date: 2015-07-23
Authors: Joseph Campbell; Joanne McPeake; Martin Shaw; Alex Puxty; Ewan Forrest; Charlotte Soulsby; Philp Emerson; Sam J Thomson; Tony M Rahman; Tara Quasim; John Kinsella Journal: Crit Care Date: 2015-10-13 Impact factor: 9.097
Authors: Alex Warren; Charlotte R Soulsby; Alex Puxty; Joseph Campbell; Martin Shaw; Tara Quasim; John Kinsella; Joanne McPeake Journal: Ann Intensive Care Date: 2017-04-04 Impact factor: 6.925