R S Guerra1, T F Amaral. 1. Faculdade de Ciências da Nutrição e Alimentação da Universidade do Porto, Portugal.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Some dynamometers previously tested in healthy adults showed variable degrees of practicality, weight and ergonomics. More practical models could also be used as a more suitable tool in gerontological field and clinical studies. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the reliability of the measurements and the performance of hand grip strength dynamometers in the elderly. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: A retirement home and a social day care centre for old people in Porto, Portugal. PARTICIPANTS AND MEASUREMENTS: The accuracy of four static grip strength dynamometers (Smedlay's Hand, Sammons Preston Rolyan Bulb, Eisenhut and the Jamar Hydraulic Hand) was first tested in laboratory. The grip strength of fifty-five elderly individuals 65-99 years was measured with the four dynamometers and the Jamar Hydraulic Hand which was used as the comparison dynamometer. RESULTS: The accuracy of the four dynamometers measurements compared to known forces was excellent (r > 0.96). A strong association between the measurements obtained by the Jamar Hydraulic and the other instruments evaluated was found (r > 0.77) but significant differences between the mean hand grip strength values evaluated with the Jamar Hydraulic and each one of the other dynamometers were found. The Bland and Altman plots confirmed that none of the three dynamometers reflects a good agreement with the Jamar Hydraulic. CONCLUSION: All four dynamometers showed excellent results regarding their laboratory tested accuracy. However, their application among elderly people rendered very different results. The Smedlay's results were closer to the Jamar Hydraulic, though none of these three dynamometers produced comparable results to the Jamar Hydraulic.
OBJECTIVE: Some dynamometers previously tested in healthy adults showed variable degrees of practicality, weight and ergonomics. More practical models could also be used as a more suitable tool in gerontological field and clinical studies. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the reliability of the measurements and the performance of hand grip strength dynamometers in the elderly. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: A retirement home and a social day care centre for old people in Porto, Portugal. PARTICIPANTS AND MEASUREMENTS: The accuracy of four static grip strength dynamometers (Smedlay's Hand, Sammons Preston Rolyan Bulb, Eisenhut and the Jamar Hydraulic Hand) was first tested in laboratory. The grip strength of fifty-five elderly individuals 65-99 years was measured with the four dynamometers and the Jamar Hydraulic Hand which was used as the comparison dynamometer. RESULTS: The accuracy of the four dynamometers measurements compared to known forces was excellent (r > 0.96). A strong association between the measurements obtained by the Jamar Hydraulic and the other instruments evaluated was found (r > 0.77) but significant differences between the mean hand grip strength values evaluated with the Jamar Hydraulic and each one of the other dynamometers were found. The Bland and Altman plots confirmed that none of the three dynamometers reflects a good agreement with the Jamar Hydraulic. CONCLUSION: All four dynamometers showed excellent results regarding their laboratory tested accuracy. However, their application among elderly people rendered very different results. The Smedlay's results were closer to the Jamar Hydraulic, though none of these three dynamometers produced comparable results to the Jamar Hydraulic.
Authors: Francien Scholten; Joseph Mugisha; Janet Seeley; Eugene Kinyanda; Susan Nakubukwa; Paul Kowal; Nirmala Naidoo; Ties Boerma; Somnath Chatterji; Heiner Grosskurth Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2011-11-24 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: A K O Wong; K A Beattie; K K H Min; C Gordon; L Pickard; A Papaioannou; J D Adachi Journal: J Musculoskelet Neuronal Interact Date: 2014-12 Impact factor: 2.041
Authors: Helen C Roberts; Holly Emma Syddall; Jonathan Sparkes; Jan Ritchie; Joe Butchart; Alastair Kerr; Cyrus Cooper; Avan Aihie Sayer Journal: Age Ageing Date: 2013-08-07 Impact factor: 10.668
Authors: Rachel Cooper; Rebecca Hardy; Avan Aihie Sayer; Yoav Ben-Shlomo; Kate Birnie; Cyrus Cooper; Leone Craig; Ian J Deary; Panayotes Demakakos; John Gallacher; Geraldine McNeill; Richard M Martin; John M Starr; Andrew Steptoe; Diana Kuh Journal: PLoS One Date: 2011-11-16 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Richard M Dodds; Holly E Syddall; Rachel Cooper; Michaela Benzeval; Ian J Deary; Elaine M Dennison; Geoff Der; Catharine R Gale; Hazel M Inskip; Carol Jagger; Thomas B Kirkwood; Debbie A Lawlor; Sian M Robinson; John M Starr; Andrew Steptoe; Kate Tilling; Diana Kuh; Cyrus Cooper; Avan Aihie Sayer Journal: PLoS One Date: 2014-12-04 Impact factor: 3.240