| Literature DB >> 19920977 |
Sadhana V Kulkarni1, Karim F Damji, Yvonne M Buys.
Abstract
Primary open angle glaucoma is a chronic optic neuropathy often requiring lifelong treatment. Patient compliance, adherence and persistence with therapy play a vital role in improved outcomes by reducing morbidity and the economic consequences that are associated with disease progression. A literature review including searches of The Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, PubMed, conference proceedings, and bibliographies of identified articles reveals the enormous public health burden in various populations due to the impact of glaucoma associated visual impairment on the overall quality of life eg, fear of blindness, inability to work in certain occupations, driving restrictions, motor vehicle accidents, falls, and general health status. Providing specific definitions for the frequently misunderstood terms "compliance, persistence and adherence" with reference to medication use is central not only for monitoring patients' drug dosing histories and clinical outcomes but also for subsequent research. In this review article, a summary of the advantages/disadvantages including cost-effectiveness of various medical approaches to glaucoma treatment, techniques employed for measuring patient compliance and actual patient preferences for therapy are outlined. We conclude by identifying the key barriers to ongoing treatment and suggest some best practices to enhance compliance and persistence.Entities:
Keywords: compliance; glaucoma; medication therapy management; persistence
Year: 2008 PMID: 19920977 PMCID: PMC2770384 DOI: 10.2147/ppa.s4163
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Patient Prefer Adherence ISSN: 1177-889X Impact factor: 2.711
Figure 1Definition of compliance and persistence. Copyright © 2008. Adapted with permission from Joyce AC, Ahuja R, Anita B, et al 2008. Medication compliance and persistence: terminology and definitions. Value Health, 11:44–7.
Taxonomy of barriers to adherence
| Categories | Sample statement |
|---|---|
| 1. Region factors | |
| Refill | I only forget to take my drops when I run out. |
| Cost of medication | When my insurance stopped paying for my medication I didn’t take my drops. |
| Complexity | It was harder when I was taking four medications, now that I am taking three it is better. |
| Change | When I first started taking the drops I had a harder time remembering. |
| Side effects | I decided to quit taking my drops because I had a bad reaction from them. |
| 2. Patient factors | |
| Knowledge/skill | Sometimes I miss my eye when taking my drops. |
| Memory | Sometimes I just forget to take my drops. |
| Motivation/health beliefs | I quit taking my drops because I didn’t see benefit to them and didn’t think they were working. |
| Co-morbidity | It is harder to keep track of my drops because I am taking so many other medications. |
| 3. Provider factors | |
| Dissatisfaction | I quit taking my drops because I was dissatisfied with my doctor’s care. |
| Communication | I stopped taking my drops because I didn’t understand initially that I need to take them forever. |
| 4. Situational/environmental factors | |
| Accountability/lack of support | Living alone I had problems taking my drops; now I live with my daughter and have no problems. |
| Major life events | Two years ago when my wife died I had a hard time taking my drops. |
| Travel/away from home | When I am on vacation it is more difficult to take my drops. |
| Competing activities | I miss my drops on Sunday mornings when I go to church. |
| Change in routine | Lifestyle changes that occur on the weekends, such as not getting up at a normal hour, cause me to forget to take my drops. |
Note: Copyright © 2003, Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. Reproduced with permission from Tsai JC, McClure CA, Ramos SE, et al 2003. Compliance barriers in glaucoma: a systematic classification. J Glaucoma, 12:393–8.
Figure 2Percentage distributions of adherence barriers. Copyright © 2003, Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. Reproduced with permission from Tsai JC, McClure CA, Ramos SE, et al 2003. Compliance barriers in glaucoma: a systematic classification. J Glaucoma, 12:393–8.
Figure 3Reasons given by glaucoma patients for missing eye drop medication. Copyright © 2008. Reproduced with permission from Kholdebarin R, Jin Y, Campbell RJ, et al 2008. Multicenter study of compliance and drop administration in glaucoma. Can J Ophthalmol, 43:454–61.
Figure 4Medication scheduler and reminder sheet (Courtesy University of Ottawa Eye Institute, Ottawa, Canada).
| 1 Adrenergic agonists | ||||
| Apraclonidine 0.5%–1.0% | Iopidine | ↓ Aqueous production | –Max effect in 4 to 5 hrs. | |
| Brimonidine 0.2% | Alphagan | ↓ Aqueous production | Duration of effect: 8–12 hr | |
| 2 Beta adrenergic blockers | ||||
| Betoxolol 0.25%–0.5% (selective Beta-1) | Betoptic | ↓ Aqueous production | Better tolerated than nonselective but not as effective | Relative SE and CI as nonselective(See below) |
| Timolol 0.1%–0.5% [nonselective] | Timoptic | Washout: 2–5 wks | Additive effects to most IOP-lowering agents | |
| Levobunolol 0.25%–0.5% [nonselective] | Betagan | Reduces IOP more than selective | Arrhythmias, heart failure, bronchospasms, airway obstruction, depression, masks hypoglycemia in IDDM | |
| 3 Carbonic anhydrase inhibitors | ||||
| Acetazolamide | Diamox | ↓ Aqueous formation | Wash-out: 3 days | |
| Indicated when topical medication is not effective or feasible | May lead to hypokalemia | |||
| Dose 125–250 mg QID or 500 mg BD for slow release | In sickle cell anemia | |||
| Topical: | ||||
| Brinzolamide | Azopt | CAI – ↓ Aqueous formation. | As monotherapy – TID | |
| Dorzolamide | Trusopt | Indicated in elevation of IOP where IOP can be deleterious to visual function | As adjunctive to topical beta blockers – BID Wash-out: 1 wk | |
| 4 Parasympathomimetics [Cholinergic drugs] | ||||
| Pilocarpine 0.5 to 4% | Isoptocarpine, pilocarpine, pilogel | Increases facility of outflow of aqueous direct action on longitudinal ciliary muscles | Pilo lowers IOP in 1 hr and lasts 6–7 hrs. Therefore used QID | |
| Carbachol | Isoptocarbachol | Indicated in elevation of IOP where IOP can be deleterious to visual function | Gel used QHS | |
| Acetylcholine 1% | Miochol – for intracameral use during surgery | Miochol used intracameral during surgery | ||
| 5 Prostaglandin derivatives | ||||
| Bimatoprost 0.03% | Lumigan | ↑ Uveal scleral outflow | IOP-lowering starts 2–4 hrs after adm. with peak effect reached within 8–12 hrs. | |
| Latanoprost 0.005% | Xalatan | Bimatoprost may also increase trabecular outflow | Once daily dose. Preferably evening | |
| Travoprost 0.004% | Travatan | |||
Notes: Several of the above medications are also available as various fixed drug combinations (typically a beta blocker paired with a prostaglandin analogue, carbonic anhydrase inhibitor or alpha-2 agonist). In general, the adverse effects of these combinations are related to the individual drug components.
Applies to all generic drugs under prostaglandin derivatives.
Abbreviation: CI, contraindications; SE, side effects; CAI, carbonic anhydrase inhibitors.