| Literature DB >> 19841735 |
Mari Jair de Jesus1, Denise Razzouk, Rangaswamy Thara, Julian Eaton, Graham Thornicroft.
Abstract
Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2009 PMID: 19841735 PMCID: PMC2758997 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000165
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS Med ISSN: 1549-1277 Impact factor: 11.069
The evidence in support of schizophrenia treatment.
| Schizophrenia Treatment | Evidence from HICs | Evidence from LMICs |
|
| Meta-analysis of early intervention for psychosis | Two longitudinal studies in rural India |
|
| A meta-analysis and two RCTs comparing FGAs and SGAs for the treatment of first psychotic episodes | RCT from China comparing the FGA haloperidol with the SGA olanzapine for first episode |
|
| Meta-analyses of treatment with haloperidol and chlorpromazine | Naturalistic trial from Brazil comparing olanzapine with FGAs in terms of effects on negative symptoms, quality of life, and the incidence of tardive dyskinesia |
| Meta-analyses of treatment with SGAs | — | |
| Meta-analysis comparing SGAs with FGAs | — | |
|
| Meta-analysis of haloperidol plus promethazine for the control of psychosis-induced aggression | Pragmatic RCT in psychiatric emergency settings in India of intra-muscular olanzapine versus intramuscular haloperidol plus promethazine for rapid tranquillization |
| — | Pragmatic RCT of intramuscular haloperidol versus intramuscular haloperidol plus promethazine in Brazil | |
|
| Meta-review of depot antipsychotic drugs | — |
| Meta-analysis of depot fluphenazine decanoate | — | |
|
| Meta-analyses of family psychosocial interventions | Study of a mutual support group for families in Hong Kong |
|
| Meta-analysis of psycho-education | RCT of psycho-education in rural China (Xinjin Country, Chengdu) |
| — | RCT of family education delivered by nurses in Beijing | |
| — | RCT of group psycho-education delivered by paramedical staff in Nigeria | |
|
| — | RCT of the efficacy of adherence therapy delivered by nurses in Chiang Mai, Thailand |
|
| — | Two longitudinal studies of CBR in rural India |
|
| Meta-analysis of the effect of CBT on positive symptoms | — |
| RCTs of the effect of CBT on persistent psychotic symptoms | — | |
|
| Meta-analysis of vocational rehabilitation | — |
|
| RCT of wellness training, health promotion for severely mentally ill adults | — |
|
| Meta-analysis of the effects of ACT on time spent in hospital and ability to live independently | — |
RCT, randomised controlled trial.
Delivering schizophrenia treatments.
| Step | How | By Whom | In What Settings |
|
| Improve mental health literacy in the community | Community-based service staff; community volunteers/extension workers linked to primary health care services, in collaboration with governmental and relevant NGOs | Community |
| Key informant identification of cases, direct social contact with people with mental illness at the individual level | — | — | |
| Community education about causes, treatability, and how to access services | — | — | |
| Social marketing at the population level | — | — | |
|
| Use local primary health care services and/or general hospitals to deliver the package | Service providers, governments, insurance providers and users | Community |
| Increase acceptability of service by involving service users and community members, establish self-help groups | — | — | |
|
| Train local/traditional practitioners to recognize and refer (key informants) | Local specialists in government/NGO, using international guidelines | Primary care |
| Train and supervise community health workers to deliver psycho-education | — | — | |
| Establish practical protocols/operationalised checklists to improve diagnostic reliability | — | — | |
|
| Train general physicians and primary health care workers to use antipsychotics | Local specialists using training materials for medical and psychosocial interventions | Primary care |
| Train general physicians and primary health care workers to identify the main side effects of medication (Parkinsonism, akathisia, dystonia, and tardive dyskinesa) | — | — | |
| Train and supervise primary health care workers to deliver psycho-educational intervention | — | — | |
|
| Train general physicians and primary health care workers to deal with agitation and dangerous behaviour | Training and supervision by local specialists in government/NGO | Primary care |
| Train general physicians and primary health care workers to recognize and treat refractory patients with clozapine | — | — | |
|
| Train general physicians and primary health care workers to maintain follow-up with physical routine examinations, assessment of compliance | Training and supervision by local specialists in government/NGO | Primary care |
|
| Occupation/livelihoods support through access to capital, skills training, inclusive education | User and carer organizations, NGOs, government and alliances, criminal justice system, and interested stakeholders and community members | Community |
| Human rights protection, prisoners' health care, access to justice in cases of abuse | — | — | |
| Advocacy for appropriate, rights-based legislation, and social protection | — | — |
NGO, nongovernmental organisation.
Package of care for schizophrenia.
| Low Resourced Setting | High Resourced Setting |
| Community-based rehabilitation | Assertive community care |
| Psycho-education | Psycho-education |
| Support for family groups delivered by nonspecialist health workers | Psychosocial family intervention |
| FGAs and SGAs wherever available | Choice of antipsychotics (SGAs and FGAs) |
| Cognitive behavioral therapy | |
| Supportive employment | |
| Wellness training |