BACKGROUND: For the world's 60 million non-facility births, addressing who is currently attending these births and what effect they have on birth outcomes is a key starting point toward improving care during childbirth. OBJECTIVE: We present a systematic review of evidence for the effect of community-based cadres-community-based skilled birth attendants (SBAs), trained traditional birth attendants (TBAs), and community health workers (CHWs)-in improving perinatal and intrapartum-related outcomes. RESULTS: The evidence for providing skilled birth attendance in the community is low quality, consisting of primarily before-and-after and quasi-experimental studies, with a pooled 12% reduction in all cause perinatal mortality (PMR) and a 22%-47% reduction in intrapartum-related neonatal mortality (IPR-NMR). Low/moderate quality evidence suggests that TBA training may improve linkages with facilities and improve perinatal outcomes. A randomized controlled trial (RCT) of TBA training showed a 30% reduction in PMR, and a meta-analysis demonstrated an 11% reduction in IPR-NMR. There is moderate evidence that CHWs have a positive impact on perinatal-neonatal outcomes. Meta-analysis of CHW packages (2 cluster randomized controlled trials, 2 quasi-experimental studies) showed a 28% reduction in PMR and a 36% reduction in early neonatal mortality rate; one quasi-experimental study showed a 42% reduction in IPR-NMR. CONCLUSION: Skilled childbirth care is recommended for all pregnant women, and community strategies need to be linked to prompt, high-quality emergency obstetric care. CHWs may play a promising role in providing pregnancy and childbirth care, mobilizing communities, and improving perinatal outcomes in low-income settings. While the role of the TBA is still controversial, strategies emphasizing partnerships with the health system should be further considered. Innovative community-based strategies combined with health systems strengthening may improve childbirth care for the rural poor, help reduce gross inequities in maternal and newborn survival and stillbirth rates, and provide an effective transition to higher coverage for facility births.
BACKGROUND: For the world's 60 million non-facility births, addressing who is currently attending these births and what effect they have on birth outcomes is a key starting point toward improving care during childbirth. OBJECTIVE: We present a systematic review of evidence for the effect of community-based cadres-community-based skilled birth attendants (SBAs), trained traditional birth attendants (TBAs), and community health workers (CHWs)-in improving perinatal and intrapartum-related outcomes. RESULTS: The evidence for providing skilled birth attendance in the community is low quality, consisting of primarily before-and-after and quasi-experimental studies, with a pooled 12% reduction in all cause perinatal mortality (PMR) and a 22%-47% reduction in intrapartum-related neonatal mortality (IPR-NMR). Low/moderate quality evidence suggests that TBA training may improve linkages with facilities and improve perinatal outcomes. A randomized controlled trial (RCT) of TBA training showed a 30% reduction in PMR, and a meta-analysis demonstrated an 11% reduction in IPR-NMR. There is moderate evidence that CHWs have a positive impact on perinatal-neonatal outcomes. Meta-analysis of CHW packages (2 cluster randomized controlled trials, 2 quasi-experimental studies) showed a 28% reduction in PMR and a 36% reduction in early neonatal mortality rate; one quasi-experimental study showed a 42% reduction in IPR-NMR. CONCLUSION: Skilled childbirth care is recommended for all pregnant women, and community strategies need to be linked to prompt, high-quality emergency obstetric care. CHWs may play a promising role in providing pregnancy and childbirth care, mobilizing communities, and improving perinatal outcomes in low-income settings. While the role of the TBA is still controversial, strategies emphasizing partnerships with the health system should be further considered. Innovative community-based strategies combined with health systems strengthening may improve childbirth care for the rural poor, help reduce gross inequities in maternal and newborn survival and stillbirth rates, and provide an effective transition to higher coverage for facility births.
Authors: Taghreed Adam; Stephen S Lim; Sumi Mehta; Zulfiqar A Bhutta; Helga Fogstad; Matthews Mathai; Jelka Zupan; Gary L Darmstadt Journal: BMJ Date: 2005-11-12
Authors: Peter J Winch; M Ashraful Alam; Afsana Akther; Dilara Afroz; Nabeel Ashraf Ali; Amy A Ellis; Abdullah H Baqui; Gary L Darmstadt; Shams El Arifeen; M Habibur Rahman Seraji Journal: Lancet Date: 2005 Aug 6-12 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Zulfiqar A Bhutta; Zahid A Memon; Sajid Soofi; Muhammad Suhail Salat; Simon Cousens; Jose Martines Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2008-06 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Abdullah H Baqui; Amanda M Rosecrans; Emma K Williams; Praween K Agrawal; Saifuddin Ahmed; Gary L Darmstadt; Vishwajeet Kumar; Usha Kiran; Dharmendra Panwar; Ramesh C Ahuja; Vinod K Srivastava; Robert E Black; Mathuram Santosham Journal: Health Policy Plan Date: 2008-07 Impact factor: 3.344
Authors: Holger J Schünemann; A Holger J Schünemann; Andrew D Oxman; Jan Brozek; Paul Glasziou; Roman Jaeschke; Gunn E Vist; John W Williams; Regina Kunz; Jonathan Craig; Victor M Montori; Patrick Bossuyt; Gordon H Guyatt Journal: BMJ Date: 2008-05-17
Authors: Abdullah H Baqui; Shams El-Arifeen; Gary L Darmstadt; Saifuddin Ahmed; Emma K Williams; Habibur R Seraji; Ishtiaq Mannan; Syed M Rahman; Rasheduzzaman Shah; Samir K Saha; Uzma Syed; Peter J Winch; Amnesty Lefevre; Mathuram Santosham; Robert E Black Journal: Lancet Date: 2008-06-07 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: C Engmann; A Garces; I Jehan; J Ditekemena; M Phiri; V Thorsten; M Mazariegos; E Chomba; O Pasha; A Tshefu; D Wallace; E M McClure; R L Goldenberg; W A Carlo; L L Wright; C Bose Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2011-11-24 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Albert Manasyan; Elwyn Chomba; Janet Moore; Dennis Wallace; Elizabeth M McClure; Marion Koso-Thomas; Waldemar A Carlo Journal: Int J Gynaecol Obstet Date: 2019-03-08 Impact factor: 3.561
Authors: Robert L Goldenberg; Elizabeth M McClure; Alan H Jobe; Beena D Kamath-Rayne; Michael G Gravette; Craig E Rubens Journal: Int J Gynaecol Obstet Date: 2013-09-04 Impact factor: 3.561
Authors: Agustín Ciapponi; Simon Lewin; Cristian A Herrera; Newton Opiyo; Tomas Pantoja; Elizabeth Paulsen; Gabriel Rada; Charles S Wiysonge; Gabriel Bastías; Lilian Dudley; Signe Flottorp; Marie-Pierre Gagnon; Sebastian Garcia Marti; Claire Glenton; Charles I Okwundu; Blanca Peñaloza; Fatima Suleman; Andrew D Oxman Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2017-09-13
Authors: Gary L Darmstadt; Yoonjoung Choi; Shams E Arifeen; Sanwarul Bari; Syed M Rahman; Ishtiaq Mannan; Habibur Rahman Seraji; Peter J Winch; Samir K Saha; A S M Nawshad Uddin Ahmed; Saifuddin Ahmed; Nazma Begum; Anne C C Lee; Robert E Black; Mathuram Santosham; Derrick Crook; Abdullah H Baqui Journal: PLoS One Date: 2010-03-24 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Elizabeth M McClure; Doris J Rouse; Emily R Macguire; Bonnie Jones; Jennifer B Griffin; Alan H Jobe; Beena D Kamath-Rayne; Craig Shaffer; Robert L Goldenberg Journal: Int J Gynaecol Obstet Date: 2013-01-11 Impact factor: 3.561