Literature DB >> 19652753

Non-disclosure of medical errors an egregious violation of ethical principles.

Ak Edwin1.   

Abstract

Medical errors will likely continue as long as clinicians remain fallible humans. Once they occur though, what should be the attitude of the medical profession? Should it be to withhold such information from patients since 'what they don't know can't hurt them' or should such information be honestly disclosed to patients and the appropriate measures taken to redress and prevent any such errors in future? Although most doctors believe that errors should be disclosed to patients when they occur, in reality, most doctors and institutions do not disclose such mishaps to patients and their families. Rather, they engage in extensive cover ups under the guise of protecting the doctor-patient relationship and not causing harm to patients. This paper, however, will show that non-disclosure of medical errors to patients and/or their families is a violation of ethical principles and cannot ever be justified.By not disclosing a medical error, the doctor conspicuously places his own interests above that of the patient to the detriment of the patient, thereby violating a patient-centered ethic. Moral courage is therefore needed if doctors are to do the right thing when medical errors occur. This moral courage can be facilitated by institutions having policies and guidelines on disclosure of errors in place, training doctors and other hospital staff on how to disclose medical errors and providing emotional support for doctors who make mistakes in their efforts to treat patients and save lives.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Nondisclosure; liability; litigation; medical errors; truth telling

Year:  2009        PMID: 19652753      PMCID: PMC2709172     

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Ghana Med J        ISSN: 0016-9560


  13 in total

1.  Handling hospital errors: is disclosure the best defense?

Authors:  A W Wu
Journal:  Ann Intern Med       Date:  1999-12-21       Impact factor: 25.391

2.  Telling the truth? Disclosure, therapeutic privilege and intersexuality in children.

Authors:  A Côté
Journal:  Health Law J       Date:  2000

3.  Lying for the patient's good.

Authors:  James D Capozzi; Rosamond Rhodes
Journal:  J Bone Joint Surg Am       Date:  2004-01       Impact factor: 5.284

Review 4.  Subtracting insult from injury: addressing cultural expectations in the disclosure of medical error.

Authors:  N Berlinger; A W Wu
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2005-02       Impact factor: 2.903

5.  To tell the truth: ethical and practical issues in disclosing medical mistakes to patients.

Authors:  A W Wu; T A Cavanaugh; S J McPhee; B Lo; G P Micco
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  1997-12       Impact factor: 5.128

6.  Patients' and physicians' attitudes regarding the disclosure of medical errors.

Authors:  Thomas H Gallagher; Amy D Waterman; Alison G Ebers; Victoria J Fraser; Wendy Levinson
Journal:  JAMA       Date:  2003-02-26       Impact factor: 56.272

7.  Moral courage in medicine--disclosing medical error.

Authors:  J Banja
Journal:  Bioethics Forum       Date:  2001

8.  Unanticipated harm to patients: deciding when to disclose outcomes.

Authors:  William M Barron; Mark G Kuczewski
Journal:  Jt Comm J Qual Saf       Date:  2003-10

Review 9.  Disclosing errors and adverse events in the intensive care unit.

Authors:  Dennis Boyle; Daniel O'Connell; Frederic W Platt; Richard K Albert
Journal:  Crit Care Med       Date:  2006-05       Impact factor: 7.598

Review 10.  Communicating with patients about medical errors: a review of the literature.

Authors:  Kathleen M Mazor; Steven R Simon; Jerry H Gurwitz
Journal:  Arch Intern Med       Date:  2004 Aug 9-23
View more
  6 in total

1.  Evaluating non-disclosure of errors and healthcare organization: a case of bioethics consultation.

Authors:  Massimiliano Colucci; Anna Aprile; Renzo Pegoraro
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2015-11

2.  Inter-Sectoral Management of Suicidal Persons in Ghana: Tensions and Prospects.

Authors:  Joseph Osafo; Johnny Andoh-Arthur
Journal:  Community Ment Health J       Date:  2020-09-30

3.  Which medical error to disclose to patients and by whom? Public preference and perceptions of norm and current practice.

Authors:  Muhammad M Hammami; Sahar Attalah; Mohammad Al Qadire
Journal:  BMC Med Ethics       Date:  2010-10-18       Impact factor: 2.652

4.  Experiences of frontline nurses with adverse medical events in a regional referral hospital in northern Ghana: a cross-sectional study.

Authors:  Robert Kaba Alhassan; Bilson Halilu; Saeed Mohammed Benin; Bentor Francis Donyor; Abubakar Yussuf Kuwaru; Dudu Yipaalanaa; Edward Nketiah-Amponsah; Martin Amogre Ayanore; Aaron Asibi Abuosi; Agani Afaya; Solomon Mohammed Salia; Japiong Milipaak
Journal:  Trop Med Health       Date:  2019-05-28

5.  Evaluation of Patient Safety Indicators in Semnan City Hospitals by Using the Patient Safety Friendly Hospital Initiative (PSFHI).

Authors:  Hassan Babamohamadi; Roghayeh Khabiri Nemati; Monir Nobahar; Seifullah Keighobady; Soheila Ghazavi; Farideh Izadi-Sabet; Zhila Najafpour
Journal:  Glob J Health Sci       Date:  2016-08-01

6.  Evaluating the expected effects of disclosure of patient safety incidents using hypothetical cases in Korea.

Authors:  Minsu Ock; Eun Young Choi; Min-Woo Jo; Sang-Il Lee
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2018-06-14       Impact factor: 3.240

  6 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.