BACKGROUND: Important clinical decisions often hinge on patients' functional status. Previous studies have shown disagreement among sources of ratings of patients' functional status. This study compared patient self-ratings, family member ratings, and physician ratings of patient function to performance-based functional testing criteria. METHODS: Five activities of daily living of 73 older patients were studied at admission to a rehabilitation unit following discharge from an acute care community hospital. Data were collected from patients, family members, and physicians and were compared with performance-based function testing. RESULTS: Patient ratings were significantly more accurate than physician ratings for walking, transferring, and telephoning. Patients were significantly more accurate than family members for rating walking and telephoning, but patients were not significantly more accurate than family members or physicians for rating eating or dressing. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that decisions about patients' functional level should be based on performance testing. If performance testing is unavailable, patients' own ratings are most accurate, followed by family ratings. Physicians' ratings are least accurate.
BACKGROUND: Important clinical decisions often hinge on patients' functional status. Previous studies have shown disagreement among sources of ratings of patients' functional status. This study compared patient self-ratings, family member ratings, and physician ratings of patient function to performance-based functional testing criteria. METHODS: Five activities of daily living of 73 older patients were studied at admission to a rehabilitation unit following discharge from an acute care community hospital. Data were collected from patients, family members, and physicians and were compared with performance-based function testing. RESULTS:Patient ratings were significantly more accurate than physician ratings for walking, transferring, and telephoning. Patients were significantly more accurate than family members for rating walking and telephoning, but patients were not significantly more accurate than family members or physicians for rating eating or dressing. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that decisions about patients' functional level should be based on performance testing. If performance testing is unavailable, patients' own ratings are most accurate, followed by family ratings. Physicians' ratings are least accurate.
Authors: J J Malmberg; S I Miilunpalo; I M Vuori; M E Pasanen; P Oja; N A Haapanen-Niemi Journal: J Epidemiol Community Health Date: 2002-12 Impact factor: 3.710
Authors: Chelsea L Reighard; Manju R Pillai; Sujani Shroff; George L Spaeth; Stephen G Schilling; Sheryl S Wizov; Joshua D Stein; Alan L Robin; Vidya Raja; Joshua R Ehrlich Journal: Ophthalmol Glaucoma Date: 2019-06-18
Authors: Anthony P Marsh; Abbie P Wrights; Eric H Haakonssen; Meredith A Dobrosielski; Elizabeth A Chmelo; Ryan T Barnard; Anthony Pecorella; Edward H Ip; W Jack Rejeski Journal: J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci Date: 2015-03-31 Impact factor: 6.053