Marinus N Verbaten1. 1. Department of Psychopharmacology, Science Faculty, Utrecht University, The Netherlands. m.n.verbaten@uu.nl
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Some studies suggest that the effects of low to moderate drinking (about 1-3 standard glasses of alcohol per day) on the brain and cognitive performance are positive. In the present study this hypothesis is investigated. METHODS: For this purpose studies on the effects of low to moderate drinking on brain structure (Magnetic Resonance Induction (MRI) studies) and on cognitive performance were analysed and discussed RESULTS: In MRI studies, a linear negative effect of alcohol consumption on brain volume was found. Furthermore, a linear decrease in grey matter concurring with a linear increase in white matter volumes as a function of number of drinks was reported in males, but not in females. Only in elderly low to moderate drinkers (aged > 65 years) there appeared to be an U-shaped relationship between alcohol consumption and white matter integrity (grade) on the one hand and cognition on the other hand. CONCLUSIONS: The changes reported in brain shrinkage, grey matter and white matter volume, as a result of low to moderate alcohol consumption sooner offer support for the contention that such drinking decreases brain health than for its beneficial effect. An exception might hold for elderly light and moderate drinkers where less white matter damage was found than in abstainers concurring with better cognitive performance. However, methodological problems impose limits on this conclusion.
OBJECTIVE: Some studies suggest that the effects of low to moderate drinking (about 1-3 standard glasses of alcohol per day) on the brain and cognitive performance are positive. In the present study this hypothesis is investigated. METHODS: For this purpose studies on the effects of low to moderate drinking on brain structure (Magnetic Resonance Induction (MRI) studies) and on cognitive performance were analysed and discussed RESULTS: In MRI studies, a linear negative effect of alcohol consumption on brain volume was found. Furthermore, a linear decrease in grey matter concurring with a linear increase in white matter volumes as a function of number of drinks was reported in males, but not in females. Only in elderly low to moderate drinkers (aged > 65 years) there appeared to be an U-shaped relationship between alcohol consumption and white matter integrity (grade) on the one hand and cognition on the other hand. CONCLUSIONS: The changes reported in brain shrinkage, grey matter and white matter volume, as a result of low to moderate alcohol consumption sooner offer support for the contention that such drinking decreases brain health than for its beneficial effect. An exception might hold for elderly light and moderate drinkers where less white matter damage was found than in abstainers concurring with better cognitive performance. However, methodological problems impose limits on this conclusion.
Authors: Benjamin J K Davis; Jean-Sebastian Vidal; Melissa Garcia; Thor Aspelund; Mark A van Buchem; Maria K Jonsdottir; Sigurdur Sigurdsson; Tamara B Harris; Vilmundur Gudnason; Lenore J Launer Journal: J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci Date: 2014-07-02 Impact factor: 6.053
Authors: Magdalena Laniewska-Dunaj; Wojciech Jelski; Karolina Orywal; Jan Kochanowicz; Robert Rutkowski; Maciej Szmitkowski Journal: Neurochem Res Date: 2013-04-27 Impact factor: 3.996
Authors: Juha Veijola; Joyce Y Guo; Jani S Moilanen; Erika Jääskeläinen; Jouko Miettunen; Merja Kyllönen; Marianne Haapea; Sanna Huhtaniska; Antti Alaräisänen; Pirjo Mäki; Vesa Kiviniemi; Juha Nikkinen; Tuomo Starck; Jukka J Remes; Päivikki Tanskanen; Osmo Tervonen; Alle-Meije Wink; Angie Kehagia; John Suckling; Hiroyuki Kobayashi; Jennifer H Barnett; Anna Barnes; Hannu J Koponen; Peter B Jones; Matti Isohanni; Graham K Murray Journal: PLoS One Date: 2014-07-18 Impact factor: 3.240