BACKGROUND: Oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) in youth is a strong predictor of mental illness yet the wide range of associations with psychiatric disorders remains largely unexplained. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the identification of irritable, headstrong and hurtful dimensions within youth oppositionality would clarify the pattern of associations between oppositionality and a wide range of psychopathology in early and adult life. METHODS: Cross-sectional data from national mental health surveys including 18,415 subjects aged 5-16 in the United Kingdom. The main outcome measures were the associations between a priori hypothesised dimensions of oppositionality with psychiatric disorders and symptoms; parent and teacher-derived information were used in multivariate regression analysis. RESULTS: Our three a priori dimensions had very different associations with disorders and symptom scales. Irritability was the only predictor of emotional disorders (parent report: OR = 3.26 [CI 95% 2.79, 3.80]; teacher report: OR = 2.78 [2.39, 3.22]); the hurtful dimension was particularly strongly associated with seeming cold-blooded or callous (parent report: beta = .32 [.27, .37]; teacher report: .33 [.30, .36]); and the headstrong dimension was most strongly associated with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD; parent report: OR = 3.21 [2.43, 4.23]; teacher report : OR = 7.18 [5.25, 9.82]). All three dimensions were associated with conduct disorder, with the headstrong dimension being the main predictor of non-aggressive symptoms (parent report: beta = .31 [.27, .34]; teacher report: .43 [.40, .45]), and with the hurtful dimension being the main predictor of aggressive symptoms (parent report: beta = .35 [.32, .39]; teacher report: .40 [.39, .42]). CONCLUSIONS: The three dimensions of oppositionality have distinctive external correlates, suggesting they may also be differential predictors of aetiology, prognosis and treatment responsiveness.
BACKGROUND:Oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) in youth is a strong predictor of mental illness yet the wide range of associations with psychiatric disorders remains largely unexplained. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the identification of irritable, headstrong and hurtful dimensions within youth oppositionality would clarify the pattern of associations between oppositionality and a wide range of psychopathology in early and adult life. METHODS: Cross-sectional data from national mental health surveys including 18,415 subjects aged 5-16 in the United Kingdom. The main outcome measures were the associations between a priori hypothesised dimensions of oppositionality with psychiatric disorders and symptoms; parent and teacher-derived information were used in multivariate regression analysis. RESULTS: Our three a priori dimensions had very different associations with disorders and symptom scales. Irritability was the only predictor of emotional disorders (parent report: OR = 3.26 [CI 95% 2.79, 3.80]; teacher report: OR = 2.78 [2.39, 3.22]); the hurtful dimension was particularly strongly associated with seeming cold-blooded or callous (parent report: beta = .32 [.27, .37]; teacher report: .33 [.30, .36]); and the headstrong dimension was most strongly associated with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD; parent report: OR = 3.21 [2.43, 4.23]; teacher report : OR = 7.18 [5.25, 9.82]). All three dimensions were associated with conduct disorder, with the headstrong dimension being the main predictor of non-aggressive symptoms (parent report: beta = .31 [.27, .34]; teacher report: .43 [.40, .45]), and with the hurtful dimension being the main predictor of aggressive symptoms (parent report: beta = .35 [.32, .39]; teacher report: .40 [.39, .42]). CONCLUSIONS: The three dimensions of oppositionality have distinctive external correlates, suggesting they may also be differential predictors of aetiology, prognosis and treatment responsiveness.
Authors: Kenneth D Gadow; L Eugene Arnold; Brooke S G Molina; Robert L Findling; Oscar G Bukstein; Nicole V Brown; Nora K McNamara; E Victoria Rundberg-Rivera; Xiaobai Li; Heidi L Kipp; Jayne Schneider; Cristan A Farmer; Jennifer L Baker; Joyce Sprafkin; Robert R Rice; Srihari S Bangalore; Eric M Butter; Kristin A Buchan-Page; Elizabeth A Hurt; Adrienne B Austin; Sabrina N Grondhuis; Michael G Aman Journal: J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2014-06-12 Impact factor: 8.829
Authors: Thomas M Olino; Daniel N Klein; Richard F Farmer; John R Seeley; Peter M Lewinsohn Journal: Compr Psychiatry Date: 2011-07-14 Impact factor: 3.735
Authors: Robert R Althoff; Frank C Verhulst; David C Rettew; James J Hudziak; Jan van der Ende Journal: J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2010-11 Impact factor: 8.829
Authors: Katharina Kircanski; Lauren K White; Wan-Ling Tseng; Jillian Lee Wiggins; Heather R Frank; Stefanie Sequeira; Susan Zhang; Rany Abend; Kenneth E Towbin; Argyris Stringaris; Daniel S Pine; Ellen Leibenluft; Melissa A Brotman Journal: JAMA Psychiatry Date: 2018-06-01 Impact factor: 21.596
Authors: Garrett M Sparks; David A Axelson; Haifeng Yu; Wonho Ha; Javier Ballester; Rasim S Diler; Benjamin Goldstein; Tina Goldstein; Mary Beth Hickey; Cecile D Ladouceur; Kelly Monk; Dara Sakolsky; Boris Birmaher Journal: J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2014-01-26 Impact factor: 8.829
Authors: Justin D Smith; Lauren Wakschlag; Sheila Krogh-Jespersen; John T Walkup; Melvin N Wilson; Thomas J Dishion; Daniel S Shaw Journal: Dev Psychopathol Date: 2019-12