Literature DB >> 18709522

Not carried away by a moonlight shadow: no evidence for associations between suicide occurrence and lunar phase among more than 65,000 suicide cases in Austria, 1970-2006.

Martin Voracek1, Lisa Mariella Loibl, Nestor D Kapusta, Thomas Niederkrotenthaler, Kanita Dervic, Gernot Sonneck.   

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Belief in lunar effects on abnormal or deviant human behavior ("moon madness") is old, common, perpetuated by the media and notably widespread among health professionals, and may thus have public health consequences. This study investigated lunar effects on one particular outcome (completed suicide) for which the literature appears unsettled, owing to some recent reports with positive findings.
METHODS: The timing of all 65,206 suicides (46,451 men; 18,755 women) officially registered in Austria between 1970 and 2006 was analyzed with respect to the phases of the moon. This was the first such study based on national data conducted outside the USA, with the database comprising the second-longest study period and the second-largest sample ever investigated in this subject area.
RESULTS: Observed proportions of both male and female suicide occurrence did not deviate from expected proportions during the new, crescent, full, and decrescent moon quarters or from those expected for 3-day windows centered around new and full moon, relative to the interphase. Subgroup analysis (by sex and year), additionally conducted for demonstration purposes, yielded results conspicuously resembling those of related studies with positive findings; namely, sporadically emerging significant findings that were entirely absent in the overall analysis and directionally erratic, thus suggesting they were spurious (false positive).
CONCLUSIONS: This large-sample evidence strongly suggests no lunar effects on the timing of completed suicide. Scattered previous evidence in support of such effects in all likelihood was spurious; that is, was due to statistical type 1 errors or erroneously taking calendrical periodicities of suicide occurrence that are real as evidence for lunar effects.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2008        PMID: 18709522     DOI: 10.1007/s00508-008-0985-6

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Wien Klin Wochenschr        ISSN: 0043-5325            Impact factor:   1.704


  43 in total

1.  Is the time of suicide a random choice? A new statistical perspective.

Authors:  Marco B L Rocchi; Chiara Perlini
Journal:  Crisis       Date:  2002

2.  Epidemiology of suicide in Austria 1990-2000: general decrease, but increased suicide risk for old men.

Authors:  Elmar Etzersdorfer; Martin Voracek; Nestor Kapusta; Gernot Sonneck
Journal:  Wien Klin Wochenschr       Date:  2005-01       Impact factor: 1.704

3.  [Suicide in children and adolescents].

Authors:  Max H Friedrich
Journal:  Wien Klin Wochenschr       Date:  2006-04       Impact factor: 1.704

4.  [Views from Dordogne, and the moon, on suicide].

Authors:  M Yvonneau
Journal:  Encephale       Date:  1996-12       Impact factor: 1.291

Review 5.  Large-scale randomized evidence: large, simple trials and overviews of trials.

Authors:  R Peto; R Collins; R Gray
Journal:  J Clin Epidemiol       Date:  1995-01       Impact factor: 6.437

6.  Geophysical variables and behavior: X. Detecting lunar periodicities: something old, new, borrowed, and true.

Authors:  J Rotton; I W Kelly; J Frey
Journal:  Psychol Rep       Date:  1983-02

7.  Lunar association with suicide.

Authors:  P K Jones; S L Jones
Journal:  Suicide Life Threat Behav       Date:  1977

8.  Suicidal asphyxiation with helium: report of three cases.

Authors:  Martin Grassberger; Astrid Krauskopf
Journal:  Wien Klin Wochenschr       Date:  2007       Impact factor: 1.704

9.  Human aggression and the lunar synodic cycle.

Authors:  A L Lieber
Journal:  J Clin Psychiatry       Date:  1978-05       Impact factor: 4.384

10.  Belief in lunar effects on human behavior.

Authors:  D E Vance
Journal:  Psychol Rep       Date:  1995-02
View more
  7 in total

1.  Predictors of suicidal behavior in a high school student population: a cross-sectional study.

Authors:  Sorin Ursoniu; Salomeia Putnoky; Brigitha Vlaicu; Cristian Vladescu
Journal:  Wien Klin Wochenschr       Date:  2009       Impact factor: 1.704

2.  Howling at the moon? The effect of lunar phases on post-surgical pain outcome.

Authors:  Marcus Komann; Claudia Weinmann; Winfried Meissner
Journal:  Br J Pain       Date:  2014-05

3.  [Key-topics in Austrian Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 2007-2017].

Authors:  Andreas Karwautz; Cvetka F Lipuš; Martin Fuchs
Journal:  Neuropsychiatr       Date:  2017-08-30

4.  Fear of darkness, the full moon and the nocturnal ecology of African lions.

Authors:  Craig Packer; Alexandra Swanson; Dennis Ikanda; Hadas Kushnir
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2011-07-20       Impact factor: 3.240

5.  A descriptive study of female suicide deaths from 2005 to 2011 in Van city, Turkey.

Authors:  Yavuz Hekimoglu; Ipek Esen Melez; Nergis Canturk; Z Zerrin Erkol; Mustafa Gokhan Dizdar; Gurol Canturk; Deniz Oguzhan Melez; Ziya Kir
Journal:  BMC Womens Health       Date:  2016-04-23       Impact factor: 2.809

6.  Lunar cycle in homicides: a population-based time series study in Finland.

Authors:  Simo Näyhä
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2019-01-15       Impact factor: 2.692

7.  Synodic lunar phases and suicide: based on 2605 suicides over 23 years, a full moon peak is apparent in premenopausal women from northern Finland.

Authors:  Victor Benno Meyer-Rochow; Tapani Hakko; Helinä Hakko; Pirkko Riipinen; Markku Timonen
Journal:  Mol Psychiatry       Date:  2020-05-13       Impact factor: 15.992

  7 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.