BACKGROUND & AIMS: There is a growing need for clinically applicable body composition assessment tools for extremely obese individuals. The objective of this research was to evaluate several bioimpedance techniques for monitoring changes in fluid, particularly intracellular water (reflecting body cell mass) after bariatric surgery. DESIGN: Fifteen extremely obese women (body mass index: 48.9+/-7.0 kg/m(2); age: 48+/-9 years) were assessed before (baseline; T1), and approximately 6 weeks after gastric bypass surgery (T2) by several multifrequency bioelectrical impedance analysis approaches (MFBIA; QuadScan 4000), a bioimpedance spectroscopy device (BIS; Hydra 4200), and multiple dilution. RESULTS: BIS provided intracellular water estimates that were comparable to criterion, based on mean comparisons, at both time points (T1: criterion: 24.2+/-3.1L, BIS: 24.0+/-3.7 L; T2: criterion: 20.6+/-3.7 L, BIS: 19.7+/-3.2L). MFBIA (with Deurenberg equations) provided comparable measures to criterion only at T2 (criterion: 20.3+/-3.7L, MFBIA: 20.6+/-2.7 L). Both MFBIA (with QuadScan proprietary equations) and BIS produced estimates of intracellular water change that were comparable to dilution. There was substantial variability in individual volume measures. CONCLUSIONS: Although MFBIA and BIS hold promise as convenient techniques for assessing fluid changes, individual variability in measurements makes them impractical for assessment of extremely obese patients in the clinical setting.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: There is a growing need for clinically applicable body composition assessment tools for extremely obese individuals. The objective of this research was to evaluate several bioimpedance techniques for monitoring changes in fluid, particularly intracellular water (reflecting body cell mass) after bariatric surgery. DESIGN: Fifteen extremely obesewomen (body mass index: 48.9+/-7.0 kg/m(2); age: 48+/-9 years) were assessed before (baseline; T1), and approximately 6 weeks after gastric bypass surgery (T2) by several multifrequency bioelectrical impedance analysis approaches (MFBIA; QuadScan 4000), a bioimpedance spectroscopy device (BIS; Hydra 4200), and multiple dilution. RESULTS:BIS provided intracellular water estimates that were comparable to criterion, based on mean comparisons, at both time points (T1: criterion: 24.2+/-3.1L, BIS: 24.0+/-3.7 L; T2: criterion: 20.6+/-3.7 L, BIS: 19.7+/-3.2L). MFBIA (with Deurenberg equations) provided comparable measures to criterion only at T2 (criterion: 20.3+/-3.7L, MFBIA: 20.6+/-2.7 L). Both MFBIA (with QuadScan proprietary equations) and BIS produced estimates of intracellular water change that were comparable to dilution. There was substantial variability in individual volume measures. CONCLUSIONS: Although MFBIA and BIS hold promise as convenient techniques for assessing fluid changes, individual variability in measurements makes them impractical for assessment of extremely obesepatients in the clinical setting.
Authors: David G Levitt; Lauren M Beckman; Jennifer R Mager; Bret Valentine; Shalamar D Sibley; Tiffany R Beckman; Todd A Kellogg; Sayeed Ikramuddin; Carrie P Earthman Journal: J Appl Physiol (1985) Date: 2010-06-17
Authors: Eline Vermeiren; Marijke Ysebaert; Kim Van Hoorenbeeck; Luc Bruyndonckx; Kristof Van Dessel; Maria Van Helvoirt; Ann De Guchtenaere; Benedicte De Winter; Stijn Verhulst; Annelies Van Eyck Journal: Eur J Clin Nutr Date: 2020-09-11 Impact factor: 4.016
Authors: Abigail J Johnson; James R Matthie; Adam Kuchnia; Levi M Teigen; Lauren M Beckman; Jennifer R Mager; Sarah A Nicklay; Urvashi Mulasi; Shalamar D Sibley; Emily Nagel; Carrie P Earthman Journal: BRASPEN J Date: 2017 Jul-Sep
Authors: Harin Rhee; Keum Sook Jang; Min Ji Shin; Jang Won Lee; Il Young Kim; Sang Heon Song; Dong Won Lee; Soo Bong Lee; Ihm Soo Kwak; Eun Young Seong Journal: PLoS One Date: 2015-07-17 Impact factor: 3.240