Literature DB >> 18616391

The renaissance of field experimentation in evaluating interventions.

William R Shadish1, Thomas D Cook.   

Abstract

Most experiments are done in laboratories. However, there is also a theory and practice of field experimentation. It has had its successes and failures over the past four decades but is now increasingly used for answering causal questions. This is true for both randomized and-perhaps more surprisingly-nonrandomized experiments. In this article, we review the history of the use of field experiments, discuss some of the reasons for their current renaissance, and focus the bulk of the article on the particular technical developments that have made this renaissance possible across four kinds of widely used experimental and quasi-experimental designs-randomized experiments, regression discontinuity designs in which those units above a cutoff get one treatment and those below get another, short interrupted time series, and nonrandomized experiments using a nonequivalent comparison group. We focus this review on some of the key technical developments addressing problems that previously stymied accurate effect estimation, the solution of which opens the way for accurate estimation of effects under the often difficult conditions of field implementation-the estimation of treatment effects under partial treatment implementation, the prevention and analysis of attrition, analysis of nested designs, new analytic developments for both regression discontinuity designs and short interrupted time series, and propensity score analysis. We also cover the key empirical evidence showing the conditions under which some nonrandomized experiments may be able to approximate results from randomized experiments.

Mesh:

Year:  2009        PMID: 18616391     DOI: 10.1146/annurev.psych.60.110707.163544

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Annu Rev Psychol        ISSN: 0066-4308            Impact factor:   24.137


  24 in total

Review 1.  Designing studies that would address the multilayered nature of health care.

Authors:  David M Murray; Michael Pennell; Dale Rhoda; Erinn M Hade; Electra D Paskett
Journal:  J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr       Date:  2010

2.  Digital detection for tobacco control: online reactions to the 2009 U.S. cigarette excise tax increase.

Authors:  John W Ayers; Benjamin M Althouse; Kurt M Ribisl; Sherry Emery
Journal:  Nicotine Tob Res       Date:  2013-12-09       Impact factor: 4.244

Review 3.  Complex problem solving: a case for complex cognition?

Authors:  Joachim Funke
Journal:  Cogn Process       Date:  2009-11-10

4.  Evidence from regression-discontinuity analyses for beneficial effects of a criterion-based increase in alcohol treatment.

Authors:  Rosely Flam-Zalcman; Robert E Mann; Gina Stoduto; Thomas H Nochajski; Brian R Rush; Anja Koski-Jännes; Christine M Wickens; Rita K Thomas; Jürgen Rehm
Journal:  Int J Methods Psychiatr Res       Date:  2012-11-20       Impact factor: 4.035

5.  Evaluating diabetes health policies using natural experiments: the natural experiments for translation in diabetes study.

Authors:  Ronald T Ackermann; O Kenrik Duru; Jeanine B Albu; Julie A Schmittdiel; Stephen B Soumerai; James F Wharam; Mohammed K Ali; Carol M Mangione; Edward W Gregg
Journal:  Am J Prev Med       Date:  2015-06       Impact factor: 5.043

6.  Evaluating the impact of environmental interventions across 2 countries: the International Bikeshare Impacts on Cycling and Collisions Study (IBICCS) Study protocol.

Authors:  Daniel Fuller; Lise Gauvin; Anne-Sophie Dubé; Meghan Winters; Kay Teschke; Elizabeth T Russo; Andi Camden; Carol Mee; Steven Marc Friedman
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2014-10-25       Impact factor: 3.295

Review 7.  Common Methodological Problems in Randomized Controlled Trials of Preventive Interventions.

Authors:  Christine M Steeger; Pamela R Buckley; Fred C Pampel; Charleen J Gust; Karl G Hill
Journal:  Prev Sci       Date:  2021-06-26

8.  The disappointing gift: dispositional and situational moderators of emotional expressions.

Authors:  Renée M Tobin; William G Graziano
Journal:  J Exp Child Psychol       Date:  2011-04-07

9.  Why Small is Too Small a Term: Prevention Science for Health Disparities, Culturally Distinct Groups, and Community-Level Intervention.

Authors:  David Henry; Carlotta Ching Ting Fok; James Allen
Journal:  Prev Sci       Date:  2015-10

10.  Role of Dentistry in Global Health: Challenges and Research Priorities.

Authors:  F N Hugo; N J Kassebaum; W Marcenes; E Bernabé
Journal:  J Dent Res       Date:  2021-02-04       Impact factor: 6.116

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.