BACKGROUND: Excellent communication between surgeons and patients is critical to helping patients to make informed decisions and is a key component of both high quality of care and patient satisfaction. Understanding racial disparities in communication is essential to provide quality care to all patients. OBJECTIVE: To examine the content and process of informed decision-making (IDM) between orthopedic surgeons and elderly white versus African American patients. To assess the association of race and patient satisfaction with surgeon communication. RESEARCH DESIGN: Analysis of audiotape recordings of office visits between orthopedic surgeons and patients. PARTICIPANTS: Eighty-nine orthopedic surgeons and 886 patients age 60 years or older in Chicago, Illinois. METHODS: Tapes were analyzed by coders for content using 9 elements of IDM and for process using 4 global ratings of the relationship-building component of communication (responsiveness, respect, listening, and sharing). Ratings by race were compared using chi analysis. Patients completed a questionnaire rating satisfaction with surgeon communication and the visit overall. Logistic analysis was used to assess the effect of race on satisfaction. RESULTS: Overall there were practically no significant differences in the content of the 9 IDM elements based on race. However, coder ratings of relationship were higher on 3 of 4 global ratings (responsiveness, respect, and listening) in visits with white patients compared with African American patients (P < 0.01). Patient ratings of communication and overall satisfaction with the visit were significantly higher for white patients. CONCLUSIONS: The content of IDM conversations does not differ by race. Yet differences in the process of relationship building and in patient satisfaction ratings were clearly present. Efforts to enhance cultural communication competence of surgeons should emphasize the skills of building relationships with patients in addition to the content of IDM.
BACKGROUND: Excellent communication between surgeons and patients is critical to helping patients to make informed decisions and is a key component of both high quality of care and patient satisfaction. Understanding racial disparities in communication is essential to provide quality care to all patients. OBJECTIVE: To examine the content and process of informed decision-making (IDM) between orthopedic surgeons and elderly white versus African American patients. To assess the association of race and patient satisfaction with surgeon communication. RESEARCH DESIGN: Analysis of audiotape recordings of office visits between orthopedic surgeons and patients. PARTICIPANTS: Eighty-nine orthopedic surgeons and 886 patients age 60 years or older in Chicago, Illinois. METHODS: Tapes were analyzed by coders for content using 9 elements of IDM and for process using 4 global ratings of the relationship-building component of communication (responsiveness, respect, listening, and sharing). Ratings by race were compared using chi analysis. Patients completed a questionnaire rating satisfaction with surgeon communication and the visit overall. Logistic analysis was used to assess the effect of race on satisfaction. RESULTS: Overall there were practically no significant differences in the content of the 9 IDM elements based on race. However, coder ratings of relationship were higher on 3 of 4 global ratings (responsiveness, respect, and listening) in visits with white patients compared with African American patients (P < 0.01). Patient ratings of communication and overall satisfaction with the visit were significantly higher for white patients. CONCLUSIONS: The content of IDM conversations does not differ by race. Yet differences in the process of relationship building and in patient satisfaction ratings were clearly present. Efforts to enhance cultural communication competence of surgeons should emphasize the skills of building relationships with patients in addition to the content of IDM.
Authors: Mary Catherine Beach; Eboni G Price; Tiffany L Gary; Karen A Robinson; Aysegul Gozu; Ana Palacio; Carole Smarth; Mollie W Jenckes; Carolyn Feuerstein; Eric B Bass; Neil R Powe; Lisa A Cooper Journal: Med Care Date: 2005-04 Impact factor: 2.983
Authors: Maria E Suarez-Almazor; Julianne Souchek; P Adam Kelly; Kimberly O'Malley; Margaret Byrne; Marsha Richardson; Chong Pak Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2005-05-23
Authors: Simon Smith; Muhammad Arsyad Bin Nordin; Tom Hinchy; Patrick Henn; Colm M P O'Tuathaigh Journal: Eur Geriatr Med Date: 2020-07-26 Impact factor: 1.710
Authors: A M Cavanaugh; M J Rauh; C A Thompson; J Alcaraz; W M Mihalko; C E Bird; C B Eaton; M C Rosal; W Li; A H Shadyab; T Gilmer; A Z LaCroix Journal: Osteoarthritis Cartilage Date: 2019-08-09 Impact factor: 6.576
Authors: Megan Johnson Shen; Emily B Peterson; Rosario Costas-Muñiz; Migda Hunter Hernandez; Sarah T Jewell; Konstantina Matsoukas; Carma L Bylund Journal: J Racial Ethn Health Disparities Date: 2017-03-08
Authors: Monica E Peek; Rita Gorawara-Bhat; Michael T Quinn; Angela Odoms-Young; Shannon C Wilson; Marshall H Chin Journal: Health Commun Date: 2012-10-10
Authors: Irene V Blair; John F Steiner; Diane L Fairclough; Rebecca Hanratty; David W Price; Holen K Hirsh; Leslie A Wright; Michael Bronsert; Elhum Karimkhani; David J Magid; Edward P Havranek Journal: Ann Fam Med Date: 2013 Jan-Feb Impact factor: 5.166
Authors: Tabor E Flickinger; Somnath Saha; Debra Roter; P Todd Korthuis; Victoria Sharp; Jonathan Cohn; Richard D Moore; Karen S Ingersoll; Mary Catherine Beach Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2015-08-20