Katri Elina Clemens1, Eva Klein, Birgit Jaspers, Eberhard Klaschik. 1. Department of Science and Research in Palliative Medicine, Centre for Palliative Medicine, University of Bonn, Von-Hompesch-Str. 1, 53123 Bonn, Germany. katri-elina.clemens@malteser.de
Abstract
AIM: There has been an ongoing debate about a legalisation of active euthanasia (AE) in Germany. Palliative care education in German medical schools seeks to foster and cultivate a negative attitude toward AE, but little is known about its effectiveness in this respect. The aim of this study was to assess attitudes toward AE among students with and without palliative medicine tuition (PMT). METHODS: The link to an anonymised online questionnaire was sent out to 1,092 third, fifth and sixth year medical students (YMS) in August-November 2006 at two German universities: university one (U1) with compulsory and additional optional PMT and university two (U2) without any PMT. Thirteen questions addressed active, passive or indirect euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (statistic: mean +/- SD (range), Wilcoxon, Whitney U Test, significance p < 0.05). RESULTS: Response rate was 17.5%; 59.2% of the questionnaires were returned from U1 and 40.8% from U2; 28.3% of the students were male. Whereas 50% of third YMS at U1 and 36.7% at U2 favoured a legalisation of AE, this was true for 22.4% sixth YMS at U1 and 35.7% at U2. At U1, the number of students who would want to make use of AE for themselves decreased considerably (70%-44.9%) but less at U2; main reasons were 'unbearable suffering' and 'circumstances that lack dignity'. Of all students, 21.1% at U1 and 37.2% at U2 could imagine to perform AE in patients, even though 72.6% at U1 and 78.2% at U2 think its legalisation would promote misuse. CONCLUSIONS: The high proportion of pro-AE attitudes gives reason to reconsider both 'standard' and palliative medicine tuition for medical students.
AIM: There has been an ongoing debate about a legalisation of active euthanasia (AE) in Germany. Palliative care education in German medical schools seeks to foster and cultivate a negative attitude toward AE, but little is known about its effectiveness in this respect. The aim of this study was to assess attitudes toward AE among students with and without palliative medicine tuition (PMT). METHODS: The link to an anonymised online questionnaire was sent out to 1,092 third, fifth and sixth year medical students (YMS) in August-November 2006 at two German universities: university one (U1) with compulsory and additional optional PMT and university two (U2) without any PMT. Thirteen questions addressed active, passive or indirect euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (statistic: mean +/- SD (range), Wilcoxon, Whitney U Test, significance p < 0.05). RESULTS: Response rate was 17.5%; 59.2% of the questionnaires were returned from U1 and 40.8% from U2; 28.3% of the students were male. Whereas 50% of third YMS at U1 and 36.7% at U2 favoured a legalisation of AE, this was true for 22.4% sixth YMS at U1 and 35.7% at U2. At U1, the number of students who would want to make use of AE for themselves decreased considerably (70%-44.9%) but less at U2; main reasons were 'unbearable suffering' and 'circumstances that lack dignity'. Of all students, 21.1% at U1 and 37.2% at U2 could imagine to perform AE in patients, even though 72.6% at U1 and 78.2% at U2 think its legalisation would promote misuse. CONCLUSIONS: The high proportion of pro-AE attitudes gives reason to reconsider both 'standard' and palliative medicine tuition for medical students.
Authors: Joachim Cohen; Isabelle Marcoux; Johan Bilsen; Patrick Deboosere; Gerrit van der Wal; Luc Deliens Journal: Eur J Public Health Date: 2006-04-26 Impact factor: 3.367
Authors: P J van der Maas; G van der Wal; I Haverkate; C L de Graaff; J G Kester; B D Onwuteaka-Philipsen; A van der Heide; J M Bosma; D L Willems Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 1996-11-28 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Wojciech Leppert; Leszek Gottwald; Mikolaj Majkowicz; Sylwia Kazmierczak-Lukaszewicz; Maria Forycka; Aleksandra Cialkowska-Rysz; Aleksandra Kotlinska-Lemieszek Journal: J Cancer Educ Date: 2013-06 Impact factor: 2.037
Authors: D Jahn-Kuch; A Domke; S Bitsche; H Stöger; A Avian; K Jeitler; N Posch; A Siebenhofer Journal: BMC Palliat Care Date: 2020-01-04 Impact factor: 3.234