BACKGROUND: Although the BMI is widely used as a measure of adiposity, it is a measure of excess weight, and its association with body fatness may differ across racial or ethnic groups. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether differences in body fatness between white, black, Hispanic, and Asian children vary by BMI-for-age, and whether the accuracy of overweight (BMI-for-age>or=Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) 95th percentile) as an indicator of excess adiposity varies by race/ethnicity. METHODS AND PROCEDURES: Total body dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) provided estimates of %body fat among 1,104 healthy 5- to 18-year-olds. RESULTS: At equivalent levels of BMI-for-age, black children had less (mean, 3%) body fatness than white children, and Asian girls had slightly higher (1%) levels of %body fat than white girls. These differences, however, varied by BMI-for-age, with the excess body fatness of Asians evident only among relatively thin children. The ability of overweight to identify girls with excess body fatness also varied by race/ethnicity. Of the girls with excess body fatness, 89% (24/27) of black girls, but only 50% (8/16) of Asian girls, were overweight (P=0.03). Furthermore, the proportion of overweight girls who had excess body fatness varied from 62% (8/13) among Asians to 100% (13/13) among whites. DISCUSSION: There are racial or ethnic differences in body fatness among children, but these differences vary by BMI-for-age. If race/ethnicity differences in body fatness among adults also vary by BMI, it may be difficult to develop race-specific BMI cut points to identify equivalent levels of %body fat.
BACKGROUND: Although the BMI is widely used as a measure of adiposity, it is a measure of excess weight, and its association with body fatness may differ across racial or ethnic groups. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether differences in body fatness between white, black, Hispanic, and Asian children vary by BMI-for-age, and whether the accuracy of overweight (BMI-for-age>or=Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) 95th percentile) as an indicator of excess adiposity varies by race/ethnicity. METHODS AND PROCEDURES: Total body dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) provided estimates of %body fat among 1,104 healthy 5- to 18-year-olds. RESULTS: At equivalent levels of BMI-for-age, black children had less (mean, 3%) body fatness than white children, and Asian girls had slightly higher (1%) levels of %body fat than white girls. These differences, however, varied by BMI-for-age, with the excess body fatness of Asians evident only among relatively thin children. The ability of overweight to identify girls with excess body fatness also varied by race/ethnicity. Of the girls with excess body fatness, 89% (24/27) of black girls, but only 50% (8/16) of Asian girls, were overweight (P=0.03). Furthermore, the proportion of overweight girls who had excess body fatness varied from 62% (8/13) among Asians to 100% (13/13) among whites. DISCUSSION: There are racial or ethnic differences in body fatness among children, but these differences vary by BMI-for-age. If race/ethnicity differences in body fatness among adults also vary by BMI, it may be difficult to develop race-specific BMI cut points to identify equivalent levels of %body fat.
Authors: M Wilkes; J Thornton; M Horlick; A Sopher; J Wang; E M Widen; R Pierson; D Gallagher Journal: Pediatr Obes Date: 2018-08-16 Impact factor: 4.000
Authors: Shirley H Huang; Elizabeth P Parks; Shiriki K Kumanyika; Sonya A Grier; Justine Shults; Virginia A Stallings; Nicolas Stettler Journal: Appetite Date: 2012-02-15 Impact factor: 3.868
Authors: Katie A Meyer; Sarah Friend; Peter J Hannan; John H Himes; Ellen W Demerath; Dianne Neumark-Sztainer Journal: Int J Pediatr Obes Date: 2011-07-12
Authors: Kumaravel Rajakumar; Javier de las Heras; Tai C Chen; SoJung Lee; Michael F Holick; Silva A Arslanian Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2011-03-02 Impact factor: 5.958
Authors: Susan B Sisson; Peter T Katzmarzyk; Sathanur R Srinivasan; Wei Chen; David S Freedman; Claude Bouchard; Gerald S Berenson Journal: Obesity (Silver Spring) Date: 2009-04-23 Impact factor: 5.002