BACKGROUND: Severe constipation may be subclassified on the basis of speed of colonic transit and efficacy of rectal evacuation. It is hypothesized that rectal evacuatory disorder (RED) may be associated with a secondary transit delay. OBJECTIVES: To determine whether scintigraphy can discriminate between slow transit constipation (STC) with or without coexistent RED on the basis of progression of isotope throughout the colon and by analyses of specific regions of interest. METHODS: One hundred ninety-six patients with STC (radio-opaque marker study) were subclassified according to results of proctography into those with a RED (STC-RED N = 30) or normal (STC-ONLY N = 41) evacuation. Patients subsequently underwent colonic scintigraphy. Distribution of generalized or left-sided patterns of colonic transit was assessed. Severities of transit delay and regional transit at specific time points were also evaluated. RESULTS: Time-activity curves and severity of global transit delay were similar between groups as were the incidences of generalized and left-sided patterns of delay. Percentage of radioisotope retention in the right colon at 18 h was higher for the STC-ONLY group (P < 0.05), but this was poorly discriminative. No differences were observed for the percentage of radioisotope retained in the left colon at later scans. CONCLUSIONS: Global and regional assessment of colonic transit by scintigraphy failed to discriminate between patients with STC with or without coexistent RED. Thus, RED is not associated with a specific pattern of transit delay and scintigraphy alone cannot predict the presence or absence of RED, knowledge of which is important for management.
BACKGROUND: Severe constipation may be subclassified on the basis of speed of colonic transit and efficacy of rectal evacuation. It is hypothesized that rectal evacuatory disorder (RED) may be associated with a secondary transit delay. OBJECTIVES: To determine whether scintigraphy can discriminate between slow transit constipation (STC) with or without coexistent RED on the basis of progression of isotope throughout the colon and by analyses of specific regions of interest. METHODS: One hundred ninety-six patients with STC (radio-opaque marker study) were subclassified according to results of proctography into those with a RED (STC-RED N = 30) or normal (STC-ONLY N = 41) evacuation. Patients subsequently underwent colonic scintigraphy. Distribution of generalized or left-sided patterns of colonic transit was assessed. Severities of transit delay and regional transit at specific time points were also evaluated. RESULTS: Time-activity curves and severity of global transit delay were similar between groups as were the incidences of generalized and left-sided patterns of delay. Percentage of radioisotope retention in the right colon at 18 h was higher for the STC-ONLY group (P < 0.05), but this was poorly discriminative. No differences were observed for the percentage of radioisotope retained in the left colon at later scans. CONCLUSIONS: Global and regional assessment of colonic transit by scintigraphy failed to discriminate between patients with STC with or without coexistent RED. Thus, RED is not associated with a specific pattern of transit delay and scintigraphy alone cannot predict the presence or absence of RED, knowledge of which is important for management.
Authors: Phil G Dinning; Linda Hunt; Vicki Patton; Teng Zhang; Michal Szczesniak; Val Gebski; Mike Jones; Peter Stewart; David Z Lubowski; Ian J Cook Journal: Am J Gastroenterol Date: 2015-04-21 Impact factor: 10.864
Authors: Philip G Dinning; Mike Jones; Linda Hunt; Sergio E Fuentealba; Jamshid Kalanter; Denis W King; David Z Lubowski; Nicholas J Talley; Ian J Cook Journal: World J Gastroenterol Date: 2011-03-21 Impact factor: 5.742