BACKGROUND: Neurosonography can assist clinicians and can provide researchers with documentation of brain lesions. Unfortunately, we know little about the reliability of sonographically derived diagnoses. OBJECTIVE: We sought to evaluate observer variability among experienced neurosonologists. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We collected all protocol US scans of 1,450 infants born before the 28th postmenstrual week. Each set of scans was read by two independent sonologists for the presence of intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) and moderate/severe ventriculomegaly, as well as hyperechoic and hypoechoic lesions in the cerebral white matter. Scans read discordantly for any of these four characteristics were sent to a tie-breaking third sonologist. RESULTS: Ventriculomegaly, hypoechoic lesions and IVH had similar rates of positive agreement (68-76%), negative agreement (92-97%), and kappa values (0.62 to 0.68). Hyperechoic lesions, however, had considerably lower values of positive agreement (48%), negative agreement (84%), and kappa (0.32). No sonologist identified all abnormalities more or less often than his/her peers. Approximately 40% of the time, the tie-breaking reader agreed with the reader who identified IVH, ventriculomegaly, or a hypoechoic lesion in the white matter. Only about 25% of the time did the third party agree with the reader who reported a white matter hyperechoic lesion. CONCLUSION: Obtaining concordance seems to be an acceptable way to assure reasonably high-quality of images needed for clinical research.
BACKGROUND: Neurosonography can assist clinicians and can provide researchers with documentation of brain lesions. Unfortunately, we know little about the reliability of sonographically derived diagnoses. OBJECTIVE: We sought to evaluate observer variability among experienced neurosonologists. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We collected all protocol US scans of 1,450 infants born before the 28th postmenstrual week. Each set of scans was read by two independent sonologists for the presence of intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) and moderate/severe ventriculomegaly, as well as hyperechoic and hypoechoic lesions in the cerebral white matter. Scans read discordantly for any of these four characteristics were sent to a tie-breaking third sonologist. RESULTS:Ventriculomegaly, hypoechoic lesions and IVH had similar rates of positive agreement (68-76%), negative agreement (92-97%), and kappa values (0.62 to 0.68). Hyperechoic lesions, however, had considerably lower values of positive agreement (48%), negative agreement (84%), and kappa (0.32). No sonologist identified all abnormalities more or less often than his/her peers. Approximately 40% of the time, the tie-breaking reader agreed with the reader who identified IVH, ventriculomegaly, or a hypoechoic lesion in the white matter. Only about 25% of the time did the third party agree with the reader who reported a white matter hyperechoic lesion. CONCLUSION: Obtaining concordance seems to be an acceptable way to assure reasonably high-quality of images needed for clinical research.
Authors: A C G Breeze; J J Cross; G A Hackett; F A Jessop; I Joubert; D J Lomas; P A K Set; A L Whitehead; C C Lees Journal: Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol Date: 2006-12 Impact factor: 7.299
Authors: J Pinto; N Paneth; E Kazam; R Kairam; S Wallenstein; W Rose; D Rosenfeld; S Schonfeld; I Stein; T Witomski Journal: Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol Date: 1988-01 Impact factor: 3.980
Authors: J Pinto-Martin; N Paneth; T Witomski; I Stein; S Schonfeld; D Rosenfeld; W Rose; E Kazam; R Kairam; V Katsikiotis Journal: Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol Date: 1992-04 Impact factor: 3.980
Authors: Kalpathy S Krishnamoorthy; Karl C K Kuban; T Michael O'Shea; Sjirk J Westra; Elizabeth N Allred; Alan Leviton Journal: J Child Neurol Date: 2010-08-19 Impact factor: 1.987
Authors: Sjirk Westra; Ira Adler; Daniel Batton; Bradford Betz; Steven Bezinque; Sara Durfee; Kirsten Ecklund; Kate Feinstein; Lynn Fordham; Joseph Junewick; Robert Lorenzo; Roy McCauley; Cindy Miller; Joanna Seibert; Karl Kuban; Elizabeth Allred; Alan Leviton Journal: J Clin Ultrasound Date: 2010-10 Impact factor: 0.910
Authors: Iris G Streimish; Richard A Ehrenkranz; Elizabeth N Allred; T Michael O'Shea; Karl C K Kuban; Nigel Paneth; Alan Leviton Journal: Early Hum Dev Date: 2012-06-23 Impact factor: 2.079
Authors: Alan Leviton; Elizabeth N Allred; Raina N Fichorova; T Michael O'Shea; Lynn A Fordham; Karl K C Kuban; Olaf Dammann Journal: Eur J Paediatr Neurol Date: 2018-01-31 Impact factor: 3.140
Authors: J W Sheehan; M Pritchard; R J Heyne; L S Brown; M A Jaleel; W D Engle; P J Burchfield; L P Brion Journal: J Perinatol Date: 2016-12-15 Impact factor: 2.521
Authors: Girija Natarajan; Seetha Shankaran; Shampa Saha; Abbot Laptook; Abhik Das; Rosemary Higgins; Barbara J Stoll; Edward F Bell; Waldemar A Carlo; Carl D'Angio; Sara B DeMauro; Pablo Sanchez; Krisa Van Meurs; Betty Vohr; Nancy Newman; Ellen Hale; Michele Walsh Journal: J Pediatr Date: 2018-02-01 Impact factor: 4.406
Authors: Nathalie L Maitre; Diane D Marshall; Wayne A Price; James C Slaughter; Thomas M O'Shea; Charles Maxfield; Ricki F Goldstein Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2009-12 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Matthew Laughon; Michael T O'Shea; Elizabeth N Allred; Carl Bose; Karl Kuban; Linda J Van Marter; Richard A Ehrenkranz; Alan Leviton Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2009-07-20 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Thomas F McElrath; Elizabeth N Allred; Kim A Boggess; Karl Kuban; T Michael O'Shea; Nigel Paneth; Alan Leviton Journal: Am J Epidemiol Date: 2009-08-27 Impact factor: 4.897