Lynne Dailey1, Rochelle E Watkins, Aileen J Plant. 1. Australian Biosecurity CRC for Emerging Infectious Disease, Division of Health Sciences, Curtin University of Technology, Perth, Western Australia. lynne.dailey@postgrad.curtin.edu.au
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: In recent years, influenza surveillance data has expanded to include alternative sources such as emergency department data, absenteeism reports, pharmaceutical sales, website access and health advice calls. This study presents a review of alternative data sources for influenza surveillance, summarizes the time advantage or timeliness of each source relative to traditional reporting and discusses the strengths and weaknesses of competing approaches. METHODS: A literature search was conducted on Medline to identify relevant articles published after 1990. A total of 15 articles were obtained that reported the timeliness of an influenza surveillance system. Timeliness was described by peak comparison, aberration detection comparison and correlation. RESULTS: Overall, the data sources were highly correlated with traditional sources and had variable timeliness. Over-the-counter pharmaceutical sales, emergency visits, absenteeism and health calls appear to be more timely than physician diagnoses, sentinel influenza-like-illness surveillance and virological confirmation. CONCLUSIONS: The methods used to describe timeliness vary greatly between studies and hence no strong conclusions regarding the most timely source/s of data can be reached. Future studies should apply the aberration detection method to determine data source timeliness in preference to the peak comparison method and correlation.
OBJECTIVE: In recent years, influenza surveillance data has expanded to include alternative sources such as emergency department data, absenteeism reports, pharmaceutical sales, website access and health advice calls. This study presents a review of alternative data sources for influenza surveillance, summarizes the time advantage or timeliness of each source relative to traditional reporting and discusses the strengths and weaknesses of competing approaches. METHODS: A literature search was conducted on Medline to identify relevant articles published after 1990. A total of 15 articles were obtained that reported the timeliness of an influenza surveillance system. Timeliness was described by peak comparison, aberration detection comparison and correlation. RESULTS: Overall, the data sources were highly correlated with traditional sources and had variable timeliness. Over-the-counter pharmaceutical sales, emergency visits, absenteeism and health calls appear to be more timely than physician diagnoses, sentinel influenza-like-illness surveillance and virological confirmation. CONCLUSIONS: The methods used to describe timeliness vary greatly between studies and hence no strong conclusions regarding the most timely source/s of data can be reached. Future studies should apply the aberration detection method to determine data source timeliness in preference to the peak comparison method and correlation.
Authors: Heather A Johnson; Michael M Wagner; William R Hogan; Wendy Chapman; Robert T Olszewski; John Dowling; Gary Barnas Journal: Stud Health Technol Inform Date: 2004
Authors: R C Welliver; J D Cherry; K M Boyer; J E Deseda-Tous; P J Krause; J P Dudley; R A Murray; W Wingert; J G Champion; G Freeman Journal: Pediatr Res Date: 1979-09 Impact factor: 3.756
Authors: Benjamin Miller; Heidi Kassenborg; William Dunsmuir; Jayne Griffith; Mansour Hadidi; James D Nordin; Richard Danila Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2004-10 Impact factor: 6.883
Authors: Cynthia Lucero-Obusan; Carla A Winston; Patricia L Schirmer; Gina Oda; Mark Holodniy Journal: Public Health Rep Date: 2017 Jul/Aug Impact factor: 2.792
Authors: W Katherine Yih; Kathryn S Teates; Allyson Abrams; Ken Kleinman; Martin Kulldorff; Robert Pinner; Robert Harmon; Stanley Wang; Richard Platt Journal: PLoS One Date: 2009-04-17 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Lisa H Gren; Christina A Porucznik; Elizabeth A Joy; Joseph L Lyon; Catherine J Staes; Stephen C Alder Journal: Influenza Res Treat Date: 2013-04-11