BACKGROUND: According to most current guidelines, stable angina pectoris patients with a high probability of having coronary artery disease can be reliably identified clinically. OBJECTIVES: To examine the reliability of clinical evaluation with or without an at-rest electrocardiogram (ECG) in patients with a high probability of coronary artery disease. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A prospective series of 357 patients referred for coronary angiography (CA) for suspected stable angina pectoris were examined by a trained physician who judged their type of pain and Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade of pain. Pretest likelihood of disease was estimated, and all patients underwent myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) followed by CA an average of 78 days later. For analysis, the investigators focused on the approximate groups of patients with more severe disease, ie, typical angina (n=187), Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade 2 pain or higher (n=176) or high (higher than 85%) estimated pretest likelihood of disease (n=142). RESULTS: In the three groups, 34% to 39% of male patients and 65% to 69% of female patients had normal MPS, while 37% to 38% and 60% to 71%, respectively, had insignificant findings on CA. Of the patients who had also an abnormal at-rest ECG, 14% to 21% of men and 42% to 57% of women had normal MPS. Sex-related differences were statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical prediction appears to be unreliable. Addition of at-rest ECG data results in some improvement, particularly in male patients, but it makes the high probability groups so small that the addition appears to be of limited clinical relevance.
BACKGROUND: According to most current guidelines, stable angina pectorispatients with a high probability of having coronary artery disease can be reliably identified clinically. OBJECTIVES: To examine the reliability of clinical evaluation with or without an at-rest electrocardiogram (ECG) in patients with a high probability of coronary artery disease. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A prospective series of 357 patients referred for coronary angiography (CA) for suspected stable angina pectoris were examined by a trained physician who judged their type of pain and Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade of pain. Pretest likelihood of disease was estimated, and all patients underwent myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) followed by CA an average of 78 days later. For analysis, the investigators focused on the approximate groups of patients with more severe disease, ie, typical angina (n=187), Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade 2 pain or higher (n=176) or high (higher than 85%) estimated pretest likelihood of disease (n=142). RESULTS: In the three groups, 34% to 39% of male patients and 65% to 69% of female patients had normal MPS, while 37% to 38% and 60% to 71%, respectively, had insignificant findings on CA. Of the patients who had also an abnormal at-rest ECG, 14% to 21% of men and 42% to 57% of women had normal MPS. Sex-related differences were statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical prediction appears to be unreliable. Addition of at-rest ECG data results in some improvement, particularly in male patients, but it makes the high probability groups so small that the addition appears to be of limited clinical relevance.
Authors: J P Pell; D Walsh; J Norrie; G Berg; A D Colquhoun; K Davidson; H Eteiba; A Faichney; A Flapan; K J Hogg; R R Jeffrey; K Jennings; J McArthur; P Mankad; K Oldroyd; A C Pell; I R Starkey Journal: Heart Date: 2001-06 Impact factor: 5.994
Authors: Ralph G Brindis; Pamela S Douglas; Robert C Hendel; Eric D Peterson; Michael J Wolk; Joseph M Allen; Manesh R Patel; Ira E Raskin; Robert C Hendel; Timothy M Bateman; Manuel D Cerqueira; Raymond J Gibbons; Linda D Gillam; John A Gillespie; Robert C Hendel; Ami E Iskandrian; Scott D Jerome; Harlan M Krumholz; Joseph V Messer; John A Spertus; Stephen A Stowers Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2005-10-18 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: Karen A Büsing; Carla Schulte-Sasse; Stephan Flüchter; Tim Süselbeck; Karl K Haase; Wolfgang Neff; Jochen G Hirsch; Martin Borggrefe; Christoph Düber Journal: Radiology Date: 2005-02-24 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: William F Fearon; Andre J Gauri; Jonathan Myers; Vinod K Raxwal; J Edwin Atwood; Victor F Froelicher Journal: Clin Cardiol Date: 2002-03 Impact factor: 2.882
Authors: Raymond J Gibbons; Jonathan Abrams; Kanu Chatterjee; Jennifer Daley; Prakash C Deedwania; John S Douglas; T Bruce Ferguson; Stephan D Fihn; Theodore D Fraker; Julius M Gardin; Robert A O'Rourke; Richard C Pasternak; Sankey V Williams Journal: J Am Coll Cardiol Date: 2003-01-01 Impact factor: 24.094
Authors: James K Min; Allison Dunning; Heidi Gransar; Stephan Achenbach; Fay Y Lin; Mouaz Al-Mallah; Matthew J Budoff; Tracy Q Callister; Hyuk-Jae Chang; Filippo Cademartiri; Erica Maffei; Kavitha Chinnaiyan; Benjamin J W Chow; Ralph D'Agostino; Augustin DeLago; John Friedman; Martin Hadamitzky; Joerg Hausleiter; Sean W Hayes; Philipp Kaufmann; Gilbert L Raff; Leslee J Shaw; Louise Thomson; Todd Villines; Ricardo C Cury; Gudrun Feuchtner; Yong-Jin Kim; Jonathon Leipsic; Hugo Marques; Daniel S Berman; Michael Pencina Journal: Am J Med Date: 2015-04-10 Impact factor: 4.965
Authors: Victor Y Cheng; Daniel S Berman; Alan Rozanski; Allison M Dunning; Stephan Achenbach; Mouaz Al-Mallah; Matthew J Budoff; Filippo Cademartiri; Tracy Q Callister; Hyuk-Jae Chang; Kavitha Chinnaiyan; Benjamin J W Chow; Augustin Delago; Millie Gomez; Martin Hadamitzky; Jörg Hausleiter; Ronald P Karlsberg; Philipp Kaufmann; Fay Y Lin; Erica Maffei; Gilbert L Raff; Todd C Villines; Leslee J Shaw; James K Min Journal: Circulation Date: 2011-10-24 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Anders Thomassen; Henrik Petersen; Axel C P Diederichsen; Hans Mickley; Lisette O Jensen; Allan Johansen; Oke Gerke; Poul-Erik Braad; Per Thayssen; Mette M Høilund-Carlsen; Werner Vach; Juhani Knuuti; Poul F Høilund-Carlsen Journal: Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging Date: 2013-08-28 Impact factor: 9.236