| Literature DB >> 17372789 |
John Song1, Dianne M Bartels, Edward R Ratner, Lucy Alderton, Brenda Hudson, Jasjit S Ahluwalia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There is little understanding about the experiences and preferences at the end of life (EOL) for people from unique cultural and socioeconomic backgrounds. Homeless individuals are extreme examples of these overlooked populations; they have the greatest risk of death, encounter barriers to health care, and lack the resources and relationships assumed necessary for appropriate EOL care. Exploring their desires and concerns will provide insight for the care of this vulnerable and disenfranchised population, as well as others who are underserved.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2007 PMID: 17372789 PMCID: PMC1829423 DOI: 10.1007/s11606-006-0046-7
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Gen Intern Med ISSN: 0884-8734 Impact factor: 5.128
Interview Guide for Focus Groups
| Questions |
|---|
| General questions |
| Do you have any experience with a serious illness or injury or a close friend or relative who had a serious illness or injury or who has died? |
| Are you concerned about dying? |
| Do you think about dying, care while dying, or death? Is this an issue that concerns you? |
| Is this an issue that you would like to talk about more? |
| Specific questions |
| Do you have any one that you can talk to about these issues? |
| Probes: Do you have family that you are in contact with? Do you have friends that you trust? Do you know any social workers, service providers, or health care providers whom you trust? |
| What concerns do you have regarding dying, care at the end of life, and death? |
| Probes: Are you concerned about what happens to your body? Your health care? Pain, symptom management, discomfort? Are you concerned about being stuck on life support? Are you concerned about dying alone? |
| If you were sick or dying, are there people you trust or love that you can get support from? Who can make decisions for you? |
| Probes: Do you have family that you are in contact with? Do you have friends that you trust? Do you know any social workers, service providers, or health care providers whom you trust? Have you ever heard of a living will or durable power of health attorney? |
| Describe a “good death.” |
| Probes: Where would you like to die? Who would you like to have by your side? Who do you need to make peace with? What would you like to have happen to your body? What are you afraid of when dying? |
| What stands in the way of you having a good death? |
| Probes: What stands in the way of good health care? What would you need to die in comfort and dignity? What are some problems with services that you have encountered? |
| What kind of services would you say would be needed so that homeless people might die in comfort and with dignity? |
Participant Demographics
| Characteristics | % |
|---|---|
| Age, years | |
| <35 | 15 |
| 36–45 | 25 |
| 46–55 | 45 |
| 56–65 | 9 |
| >65 | 6 |
| Gender | |
| Female | 35 |
| Race | |
| Hispanic or Latino | 2 |
| Not Hispanic or Latino | 2 |
| American Indian or Alaskan Native | 36 |
| Asian | 2 |
| Black or African American | 27 |
| Native African | 2 |
| Hawaiian/other Pacific Islander | 0 |
| White | 22 |
| Not reported | 7 |
| Years of education | |
| 5–8 | 8 |
| 9–11 | 39 |
| 12–15 | 32 |
| 16+ | 8 |
| Not reported | 13 |
Domains and Themes of EOL Care Expressed by Homeless People
| Domain | Definitions | Representative quote(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Personal themes | ||
| Experience with EOL care | Experience with deaths of loved ones, friends, and acquaintances on the streets or personal experiences with illness or injury, and the care received | I’ve had a lot of tragedy. My girlfriend died in my arms with my baby. She was four months pregnant at the time...and she comes back in my dreams. |
| He had a stroke and was on dialysis. Me and him, being about the same age, it made me fear for my life. | ||
| Fears and uncertainties | Concerns and fears about dying and EOL care | Me? I’d just like to be remembered by somebody. |
| The only thing I’m worried about is that I don’t want to die on the streets. | ||
| After I’ve passed, my biggest fear would be not making it back home to Canada and my reservation. | ||
| ...they’ll throw you in a pauper’s grave someplace and nobody’s going to mourn you. | ||
| Preferences/wishes/hopes | Possibilities related to what would be a “good death” | If that was to happen, I would want it to happen some place where it was noticeable. Yeah, you may be dead there for three, four years...I’ll be somewhere where nobody could find me. |
| But also, once you see the doctor, the doctor should spend a little more time and get to know you a little bit better and show a little more compassion. | ||
| Advance care planning/documentation | Strategies to influence outcomes in the event of death or serious illness | You gotta have it wrote down, or else they’ll do just what they want. |
| I’m going to have one of those made out, a living will, because if I end up in the hospital, I don’t think I’d want no life support keeping me alive. | ||
| My will says that if I go into a diabetic coma or if I get hit by a car, they can start life-saving techniques, and then my brother Bob’s name is on that. They are to call him and say John’s in the hospital, doesn’t look good; do you want to come down and sign the papers to pull the plug; we will try to keep him going for some time to see if he improves. If he doesn’t improve, then come down. That is exactly how it’s worded. | ||
| Spirituality/religion | Influence and role that an individual’s spirituality or religious convictions has on dying and EOL care | Personally, death comes like peace, but like John said, we look forward to it if we’re Christian because I can go and get my reincarnate body and dance without this one. |
| Veteran status | Thoughts about death and EOL care related to having served in the armed forces | Even though I’m a serviceman, if I was buried in a national cemetery, I feel that my soul would be lost. |
| I went to get medical care, something that they guaranteed me for life. They looked at me and said, ‘OK, you have an honorable discharge.’ As a matter of fact, I have two. ‘Do you have insurance on your job?’ and I’m like, whoa. The insurance on my job, OK, when I signed these contracts you didn’t say that my insurance would be primary. You said that you would take care of it. So the VA does nothing. | ||
| Relational themes | ||
| Relationships with known people | How current relationships with family, friends, and peers affect desires and fears about dying and EOL care | Most of these guys, they don’t want their family to know. They ask you what happened. Why are you homeless? What’s the problem? |
| But I notice that homeless people, or street punks, whatever you call them, whatever is right for them, prostitutes or whatever, sometimes these type of people, another street person they have known for years and seems more like a family member than their own family. For me that is considered a family member. | ||
| They’d be there for me, but I wouldn’t want them to make all them changes. It takes a lot of money to travel and I don’t want them wasting money. Not because I ain’t worth the money, but I don’t want them. | ||
| Relationships with strangers | How individuals’ relationship with institutions and its representatives influence their views dying and EOL care | Have a doctor, an intern, or even have a medical student for a doctor, come and work at a shelter for a week to two weeks, just to see how it is, to get woke up at 6:00 in the morning and booted out, and getting a cold bowl of cereal from the branch for breakfast, and just shadowing somebody that has been homeless or is homeless, just to feel what it’s like to, if just to say ‘I know this guy; he’s homeless and this needs to be taken care of right away’ and not making him wait. Then they will have an ideal of what it’s like being homeless. |
| The doctor called me a goddamn drug addict and told me to get the hell out of his office. | ||
| Communication tools/strategies | The communication between the subjects and their loved or valued ones, and strategies homeless persons have to communicate with loved ones during a health care crisis or if unable to communicate directly | My sister, I put her name on everything that I have. There can be contact with her and she will communicate with my daughter. |
| My living will says my family will have no say or discussion of what is done. Basically, they don’t know me, so why should they have a say in whether I live or not. | ||
| I made sure to talk to him (nephew) on the telephone. It just came into my mind. I said, ‘I’m going to leave this in your hands. I’m going down hill now. | ||
| Environmental | ||
| Barriers/facilitators to good EOL care | Barriers or facilitators identified by subjects to good EOL care | They don’t give you proper medical care because they know you are homeless. |
| They think because we live in the streets, we’re all junkies that don’t feel no pain. | ||
| Even if your family is not around at the hospital, there are these great hospice people. If you could spend your last time talking with them...that would be a good death. | ||
| Living without life insurance, who’s going to put me away—stuff like that? | ||
| I had cancer just last year. My fear was being alone because my children ain’t here. But I had support from the people at Listening House, friends. | ||
| Participant-suggested interventions | Interventions suggested by participants to improve dying and EOL care for homeless persons | What we do need is a shelter somewhere between Minneapolis and St. Paul that would be fully staffed 24/7...and if you came out and just had surgery, you could go there... |
EOL end of life