George F Gowen1. 1. Pennsylvania Hospital, Philadelphia, PA, USA. george.gowen@verizon.net
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Long-tube decompression has achieved a 75% to 80% success rate in 5 studies, and the short tube had a 40% success rate in 3 studies. METHODS: From 1984 to 1991, an endoscope-advanced long intestinal tube was placed into the jejunum in 17 patients, and from 1992 to 2004 an improved long tube was used in 23 patients. Costs were calculated for each type of procedure. RESULTS: In the first group, decompression was successful in 12 of 17 patients (70%). In the second group, decompression was successful in 21 of 23 patients (90%). The average charges were as follows: for the short tube the average charge was 21,687 dollars, and for the long tube the average charge was 11,316 dollars. CONCLUSIONS: First, by using the improved long tube, which was advanced endoscopically into the jejunum, the success rate was 90% with procedures that are standard in every hospital. Second, most patients who fail the short-tube procedure are candidates for the long tube. Third, the improved long tube, endoscopically advanced into the jejunum, is recommended strongly because it provides significant advantages, both clinically and economically, over the short-tube approach. A prospective randomized study comparing the short tube for 3 days versus the long tube for 3 days is recommended to prove the superiority of the long tube in patients with small-bowel obstruction.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Long-tube decompression has achieved a 75% to 80% success rate in 5 studies, and the short tube had a 40% success rate in 3 studies. METHODS: From 1984 to 1991, an endoscope-advanced long intestinal tube was placed into the jejunum in 17 patients, and from 1992 to 2004 an improved long tube was used in 23 patients. Costs were calculated for each type of procedure. RESULTS: In the first group, decompression was successful in 12 of 17 patients (70%). In the second group, decompression was successful in 21 of 23 patients (90%). The average charges were as follows: for the short tube the average charge was 21,687 dollars, and for the long tube the average charge was 11,316 dollars. CONCLUSIONS: First, by using the improved long tube, which was advanced endoscopically into the jejunum, the success rate was 90% with procedures that are standard in every hospital. Second, most patients who fail the short-tube procedure are candidates for the long tube. Third, the improved long tube, endoscopically advanced into the jejunum, is recommended strongly because it provides significant advantages, both clinically and economically, over the short-tube approach. A prospective randomized study comparing the short tube for 3 days versus the long tube for 3 days is recommended to prove the superiority of the long tube in patients with small-bowel obstruction.
Authors: Theunis J van Zyl; Patrick B Murphy; Laura Allen; Neil G Parry; Ken Leslie; Kelly N Vogt Journal: Can J Surg Date: 2018-08 Impact factor: 2.089
Authors: Theunis J van Zyl; Patrick B Murphy; Laura Allen; Neil G Parry; Ken Leslie; Kelly N Vogt Journal: Can J Surg Date: 2018-06-01 Impact factor: 2.089