BACKGROUND:Zinc gluconate and zinc acetate lozenges have been reported to shorten the duration of common colds in a dose-response manner when the amount of the active ingredient, positively charged zinc ions, is sufficient. OBJECTIVE: To improve results using a zinc gluconate nasal spray with zinc orotate lozenges. DESIGN: Double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial. SETTING:Private physician's clinic in Austin, Texas. PARTICIPANTS: Seventy-seven volunteers, all of whom had 2 or more signs and symptoms of common colds (with at least 1 nasal symptom) on enrollment in the study. METHODS:Zinc gluconate nasal spray (10 mmol) or placebo was used every 15 to 30 minutes, and lozenges were used each several hours to reduce duration and severity of common colds. An intention of treatment was to keep the nasal tissues wet with zinc gluconate solution during wakeful hours. RESULTS: After 7 days of treatment, 10 of 16 (63%) zinc-treated patients were asymptomatic compared to 9 of 17 (53%) placebo-treated patients (P = .57). This treatment caused olfactory region pain in some patients and did not reduce the duration or severity of common colds. Treatment did not produce anosmia, which has been reported in other studies following olfactory region administration of ionic zinc in many species and in humans from zinc nasal sprays and gels. CONCLUSION: We contend that it is unethical to introduce any potentially permanent anosmia-inducing agent such as zinc or other heavy metals into the interior of the nose in a manner that could result in contact with the olfactory region to treat a temporary discomfort such as a common cold or allergy. We found no reason to recommend intranasal zinc gluconate or zinc orotate lozenges in treating common colds.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND:Zinc gluconate and zinc acetate lozenges have been reported to shorten the duration of common colds in a dose-response manner when the amount of the active ingredient, positively charged zinc ions, is sufficient. OBJECTIVE: To improve results using a zinc gluconate nasal spray with zinc orotate lozenges. DESIGN: Double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial. SETTING: Private physician's clinic in Austin, Texas. PARTICIPANTS: Seventy-seven volunteers, all of whom had 2 or more signs and symptoms of common colds (with at least 1 nasal symptom) on enrollment in the study. METHODS:Zinc gluconate nasal spray (10 mmol) or placebo was used every 15 to 30 minutes, and lozenges were used each several hours to reduce duration and severity of common colds. An intention of treatment was to keep the nasal tissues wet with zinc gluconate solution during wakeful hours. RESULTS: After 7 days of treatment, 10 of 16 (63%) zinc-treated patients were asymptomatic compared to 9 of 17 (53%) placebo-treated patients (P = .57). This treatment caused olfactory region pain in some patients and did not reduce the duration or severity of common colds. Treatment did not produce anosmia, which has been reported in other studies following olfactory region administration of ionic zinc in many species and in humans from zinc nasal sprays and gels. CONCLUSION: We contend that it is unethical to introduce any potentially permanent anosmia-inducing agent such as zinc or other heavy metals into the interior of the nose in a manner that could result in contact with the olfactory region to treat a temporary discomfort such as a common cold or allergy. We found no reason to recommend intranasal zinc gluconate or zinc orotate lozenges in treating common colds.
Authors: Susan Arentz; Jennifer Hunter; Guoyan Yang; Joshua Goldenberg; Jennifer Beardsley; Stephen P Myers; Dominik Mertz; Stephen Leeder Journal: Adv Integr Med Date: 2020-08-01
Authors: Jae H Lim; Greg E Davis; Zhenshan Wang; Vicky Li; Yuping Wu; Tessa C Rue; Daniel R Storm Journal: PLoS One Date: 2009-10-30 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Jennifer Hunter; Susan Arentz; Joshua Goldenberg; Guoyan Yang; Jennifer Beardsley; Stephen P Myers; Dominik Mertz; Stephen Leeder Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2021-11-02 Impact factor: 2.692