Hypermutability impedes cooperation in pathogenic bacteria.

When the supply of beneficial mutations limits adaptation, bacterial mutator alleles can reach high frequencies by hitchhiking with advantageous mutations. However, when populations are well adapted to their environments, the increased rate of deleterious mutations makes hypermutability selectively disadvantageous. Here, we consider a further cost of hypermutability: its potential to break down cooperation (group-beneficial behavior that is costly to the individual). This probably occurs for three reasons. First, an increased rate at which 'cheating' genotypes are generated; second, an increased probability of producing efficient cheats; and third, a decrease in relatedness (not addressed in the present study). We used Pseudomonas aeruginosa's production of extracellular iron-scavenging molecules, siderophores, to determine if cheating evolved more readily in mutator populations. Siderophore production is costly to individual bacteria but benefits all nearby cells. Siderophore-deficient cheats therefore have a selective advantage within populations. We observed the de novo evolution and subsequent increase in frequency of siderophore cheats within both wild-type and mutator populations for 200 generations. Cheats appeared and increased in frequency more rapidly in mutator populations. The presence of cheats was costly to the group, as shown by a negative correlation between cheat frequency and population density.