Y Tokuda1, H Miyasato, G H Stein. 1. Department of Medicine, Okinawa Chubu Hospital, Japan. tokuyasu@orange.ocn.ne.jp
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Existing prediction models for the risk of bacteraemia are complex and difficult to use. Physicians are likely to use a model only if it is simple and sensitive. AIM: To develop a simple classification algorithm predicting the risk of bacteraemia. DESIGN: Hospital-based study. METHODS: We enrolled 526 adult consecutive patients with acute febrile illness (40 with bacteraemia) presenting to the emergency department at a community hospital in Okinawa, Japan. Recursive partitioning analysis was used to build the classification algorithm with V-fold cross-validation. We used two clinical scenarios: in the first, laboratory tests were not available; in the second, they were. RESULTS: The two prediction algorithms generated three different risk groups for bacteraemia. In the first scenario, the important variables were chills, pulse, and physician diagnosis of a low-risk site. The low-risk group from this first algorithm included 68% of the total patients; sensitivity was 87.5% and the misclassification rate was 1.4% (5/358). In the second scenario, the important variables were chills, C-reactive protein, and physician diagnosis of a low-risk site. The low-risk group for the second algorithm included 62% of the total patients; sensitivity was 92.5% and misclassification rate 0.9% (3/328). The algorithms had negative predictive values of 98.6% (first scenario) and 99.1% (second). DISCUSSION: This simple and sensitive prediction algorithm may be useful for identifying patients at low risk of bacteraemia. Prospective validation is needed in other settings.
BACKGROUND: Existing prediction models for the risk of bacteraemia are complex and difficult to use. Physicians are likely to use a model only if it is simple and sensitive. AIM: To develop a simple classification algorithm predicting the risk of bacteraemia. DESIGN: Hospital-based study. METHODS: We enrolled 526 adult consecutive patients with acute febrile illness (40 with bacteraemia) presenting to the emergency department at a community hospital in Okinawa, Japan. Recursive partitioning analysis was used to build the classification algorithm with V-fold cross-validation. We used two clinical scenarios: in the first, laboratory tests were not available; in the second, they were. RESULTS: The two prediction algorithms generated three different risk groups for bacteraemia. In the first scenario, the important variables were chills, pulse, and physician diagnosis of a low-risk site. The low-risk group from this first algorithm included 68% of the total patients; sensitivity was 87.5% and the misclassification rate was 1.4% (5/358). In the second scenario, the important variables were chills, C-reactive protein, and physician diagnosis of a low-risk site. The low-risk group for the second algorithm included 62% of the total patients; sensitivity was 92.5% and misclassification rate 0.9% (3/328). The algorithms had negative predictive values of 98.6% (first scenario) and 99.1% (second). DISCUSSION: This simple and sensitive prediction algorithm may be useful for identifying patients at low risk of bacteraemia. Prospective validation is needed in other settings.
Authors: June-Il Bae; Shin Ahn; Yoon-Seon Lee; Won Young Kim; Jae Ho Lee; Bum Jin Oh; Kyung Soo Lim Journal: Intern Emerg Med Date: 2016-05-10 Impact factor: 3.397
Authors: Boris P Ehrenstein; Vera Ehrenstein; Christine Henke; Hans-Jörg Linde; Bernd Salzberger; Jürgen Schölmerich; Thomas Glück Journal: BMC Infect Dis Date: 2008-10-28 Impact factor: 3.090
Authors: Svenja Laukemann; Nina Kasper; Prasad Kulkarni; Deborah Steiner; Anna Christina Rast; Alexander Kutz; Susan Felder; Sebastian Haubitz; Lukas Faessler; Andreas Huber; Christoph A Fux; Beat Mueller; Philipp Schuetz Journal: Medicine (Baltimore) Date: 2015-12 Impact factor: 1.817