BACKGROUND: Total knee replacement is now the most common joint replacement procedure performed in Ontario, and many patients require bilateral replacement. However, whether bilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) should be staged or simultaneous is hotly debated. To determine the current common operative practices of orthopedic surgeons in Ontario, we carried out a province-wide survey. METHODS: Orthopedic surgeons from Ontario listed in the 1999 Canadian Medical Directory or the membership list of the Canadian Orthopaedic Association were sent questionnaires, asking about their practice in the timing of bilateral TKA, tourniquet use, type of guide and use of techniques to minimize fat embolization. RESULTS: Of the 416 surveys mailed, 219 (53%) surgeons responded. The majority responded that they perform staged bilateral TKA (28% 3-mo interval and 37% 6-mo interval). Simultaneous TKA with 2 teams was the least performed procedure (2%). When performing bilateral TKA, 95% of surgeons use an intramedullary femoral alignment guide, 78% utilize an over-reamed entry hole and 53% suction the canal before inserting the guide rod. With respect to the tibia, 32% use an intramedullary guide, 60% over-ream the entry hole and 60% suction the entry hole; 22% of surgeons stated that they had never considered over-reaming or suctioning the canal to minimize fat embolization. CONCLUSIONS: There is no consensus regarding the timing of bilateral TKA in Ontario. Furthermore, many surgeons are not overdrilling or suctioning the femoral canal despite evidence in the literature that overdrilling may be beneficial in decreasing fat embolization. Further research is required to compare the risk of complications of bilateral TKA after staged versus simultaneous TKA.
BACKGROUND: Total knee replacement is now the most common joint replacement procedure performed in Ontario, and many patients require bilateral replacement. However, whether bilateral total knee arthroplasty (TKA) should be staged or simultaneous is hotly debated. To determine the current common operative practices of orthopedic surgeons in Ontario, we carried out a province-wide survey. METHODS: Orthopedic surgeons from Ontario listed in the 1999 Canadian Medical Directory or the membership list of the Canadian Orthopaedic Association were sent questionnaires, asking about their practice in the timing of bilateral TKA, tourniquet use, type of guide and use of techniques to minimize fat embolization. RESULTS: Of the 416 surveys mailed, 219 (53%) surgeons responded. The majority responded that they perform staged bilateral TKA (28% 3-mo interval and 37% 6-mo interval). Simultaneous TKA with 2 teams was the least performed procedure (2%). When performing bilateral TKA, 95% of surgeons use an intramedullary femoral alignment guide, 78% utilize an over-reamed entry hole and 53% suction the canal before inserting the guide rod. With respect to the tibia, 32% use an intramedullary guide, 60% over-ream the entry hole and 60% suction the entry hole; 22% of surgeons stated that they had never considered over-reaming or suctioning the canal to minimize fat embolization. CONCLUSIONS: There is no consensus regarding the timing of bilateral TKA in Ontario. Furthermore, many surgeons are not overdrilling or suctioning the femoral canal despite evidence in the literature that overdrilling may be beneficial in decreasing fat embolization. Further research is required to compare the risk of complications of bilateral TKA after staged versus simultaneous TKA.
Authors: Stavros G Memtsoudis; Alejandro González Della Valle; Melanie C Besculides; Licia Gaber; Thomas P Sculco Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2008-08-14 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Stavros G Memtsoudis; Mary Hargett; Linda A Russell; Javad Parvizi; William L Cats-Baril; Ottokar Stundner; Thomas P Sculco Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2013-04-06 Impact factor: 4.176