What are the roles of substrate-assisted catalysis and proximity effects in peptide bond formation by the ribosome?

The action of the peptidyl transferase center of the large ribosomal unit presents a fundamental step in the evolution from the RNA world to the protein world. Thus, it is important to understand the origin of the catalytic power of this ancient enzyme. Earlier studies suggested that the ribosome catalyzes peptide bond formation by using one of its groups as a general base, while more recent works have proposed that the catalysis is due to proximity effects or to substrate-assisted catalysis. However, the actual nature of the catalytic mechanism remains controversial. This work addresses the origin of the catalytic power of the ribosome by using computer simulation approaches and comparing the energetics of the peptide bond formation in the ribosome and in water. It is found that a significant part of the observed activation entropy of the reference solution reaction is due to solvation entropy, and that the proximity effect is smaller than previously thought. It is also found that the 2'-OH of the A76 ribose, which is associated with a large rate acceleration in the ribosome reaction, does not catalyze peptide bond formation in water. Thus, the catalytic effect cannot be attributed to substrate-assisted catalysis but rather to the effect of the ribosome on the reacting system. Overall, our calculations indicate that the reduction of the activation free energy is mainly due to electrostatic effects. The nature of these effects and their relationship to catalytic factors in modern enzymes is analyzed and discussed.