PURPOSE: We examined 512 published cost-utility analyses (CUAs) in the U.S. and other developed countries from 1976 through 2001 to determine: 1) the types of interventions studied; 2) whether they cover diseases and conditions with the highest burden; and, 3) to what extent they have covered leading health concerns defined by the Healthy People 2010 report. DATA AND METHODS: We compared rankings of the most common diseases covered by the CUAs to rankings of U.S. disease burden. We also examined the extent to which CUAs covered key Healthy People 2010 priorities. RESULTS: CUAs have focused mostly on pharmaceuticals (40%) and surgical procedures (16%). When compared to leading causes of DALYs, the data show overrepresentation of CUAs in cerebrovascular disease, diabetes, breast cancer, and HIV/AIDS, and underrepresentation in depression and bipolar disorder, injuries, and substance abuse disorders. Few CUAs have targeted Healthy People 2010 areas, such as physical activity. CONCLUSIONS: Published CUAs are associated with burden measures, but have not covered certain important health problems. These discrepancies do not alone indicate that society has been targeting resources for research inefficiently, but they do suggest the need to formalize the question of where each CUA research dollar might do the most good.
PURPOSE: We examined 512 published cost-utility analyses (CUAs) in the U.S. and other developed countries from 1976 through 2001 to determine: 1) the types of interventions studied; 2) whether they cover diseases and conditions with the highest burden; and, 3) to what extent they have covered leading health concerns defined by the Healthy People 2010 report. DATA AND METHODS: We compared rankings of the most common diseases covered by the CUAs to rankings of U.S. disease burden. We also examined the extent to which CUAs covered key Healthy People 2010 priorities. RESULTS: CUAs have focused mostly on pharmaceuticals (40%) and surgical procedures (16%). When compared to leading causes of DALYs, the data show overrepresentation of CUAs in cerebrovascular disease, diabetes, breast cancer, and HIV/AIDS, and underrepresentation in depression and bipolar disorder, injuries, and substance abuse disorders. Few CUAs have targeted Healthy People 2010 areas, such as physical activity. CONCLUSIONS: Published CUAs are associated with burden measures, but have not covered certain important health problems. These discrepancies do not alone indicate that society has been targeting resources for research inefficiently, but they do suggest the need to formalize the question of where each CUA research dollar might do the most good.
Authors: Peter J Neumann; Megan Farquhar; Colby L Wilkinson; Mackenzie Lowry; Marthe Gold Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2016-09-15 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Jeffrey M Pyne; Shanti Tripathi; Michael French; Kathryn McCollister; Richard C Rapp; Brenda M Booth Journal: Addiction Date: 2011-03 Impact factor: 6.526
Authors: Seija K Kromm; Jennifer Bethell; Ferne Kraglund; Sarah A Edwards; Audrey Laporte; Peter C Coyte; Wendy J Ungar Journal: Qual Life Res Date: 2011-10-29 Impact factor: 4.147
Authors: Ferrán Catalá-López; Anna García-Altés; Elena Alvarez-Martín; Ricard Gènova-Maleras; Consuelo Morant-Ginestar; Antoni Parada Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2011-04-13 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Kathryn A Phillips; Julie Ann Sakowski; Julia Trosman; Michael P Douglas; Su-Ying Liang; Peter Neumann Journal: Genet Med Date: 2013-10-17 Impact factor: 8.822