D M Macgregor1, L McKie. 1. Accident & Emergency Department, Royal Aberdeen Children's Hospital, Foresterhill, Aberdeen, AB25 2ZG, Scotland. diana.macgregor@nhs.net
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the usage of computed tomography (CT) head scanning in children at the Royal Aberdeen Children's Hospital after the publication of the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines on the management of head injury. METHODS: The Accident and Emergency case records of all children presenting with a head injury over a three month period were reviewed and the number of attendances, radiographs, and CT head scans undertaken were noted. Also noted was the number of additional CT head scans that would have been performed if the NICE guidelines had been rigidly followed. RESULTS: Five hundred and thirty seven children were included in the study: 67% were boys. Two hundred and ten (39%) had skull radiographs: six demonstrated skull fractures and eight (1.5%) underwent CT head scan, with one positive report of a skull fracture. There were no reports of intracranial abnormalities. Ninety nine (18.4%) were admitted. Strictly applying all the NICE criteria for CT scanning would have resulted in an additional 54 patients being scanned. CONCLUSION: Rigid adherence to the NICE guidelines in all children with head injuries would have resulted in an almost eightfold increase in CT head scans performed. None of these children had clinical signs of intracranial injury and would have been exposed to a large amount of ionising radiation. The use of guidelines in practice must always be considered in conjunction with clinical judgement.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the usage of computed tomography (CT) head scanning in children at the Royal Aberdeen Children's Hospital after the publication of the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines on the management of head injury. METHODS: The Accident and Emergency case records of all children presenting with a head injury over a three month period were reviewed and the number of attendances, radiographs, and CT head scans undertaken were noted. Also noted was the number of additional CT head scans that would have been performed if the NICE guidelines had been rigidly followed. RESULTS: Five hundred and thirty seven children were included in the study: 67% were boys. Two hundred and ten (39%) had skull radiographs: six demonstrated skull fractures and eight (1.5%) underwent CT head scan, with one positive report of a skull fracture. There were no reports of intracranial abnormalities. Ninety nine (18.4%) were admitted. Strictly applying all the NICE criteria for CT scanning would have resulted in an additional 54 patients being scanned. CONCLUSION: Rigid adherence to the NICE guidelines in all children with head injuries would have resulted in an almost eightfold increase in CT head scans performed. None of these children had clinical signs of intracranial injury and would have been exposed to a large amount of ionising radiation. The use of guidelines in practice must always be considered in conjunction with clinical judgement.
Authors: Per Hall; Hans-Olov Adami; Dimitrios Trichopoulos; Nancy L Pedersen; Pagona Lagiou; Anders Ekbom; Martin Ingvar; Marie Lundell; Fredrik Granath Journal: BMJ Date: 2004-01-03
Authors: M Brookes; R MacMillan; S Cully; E Anderson; S Murray; A D Mendelow; B Jennett Journal: J Epidemiol Community Health Date: 1990-06 Impact factor: 3.710
Authors: Linda Papa; Lawrence M Lewis; Jay L Falk; Zhiqun Zhang; Salvatore Silvestri; Philip Giordano; Gretchen M Brophy; Jason A Demery; Neha K Dixit; Ian Ferguson; Ming Cheng Liu; Jixiang Mo; Linnet Akinyi; Kara Schmid; Stefania Mondello; Claudia S Robertson; Frank C Tortella; Ronald L Hayes; Kevin K W Wang Journal: Ann Emerg Med Date: 2011-11-08 Impact factor: 5.721