P Tallgren1, S Vanhatalo, K Kaila, J Voipio. 1. Department of Biological and Environmental Sciences, University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 65, 00014 Helsinki, Finland.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To test the applicability of different types of commercially available electrodes and electrode gels or pastes for recording of slow EEG potentials. METHODS: Experiments were carried out on six types of reusable electrodes (silver, tin and gold cup electrodes, sintered silver-silver chloride (Ag|AgCl), platinum, stainless steel), six disposable Ag|AgCl electrode models, and nine gels or pastes. We studied the parameters, which are critical in slow-potential recording, such as polarization, initial and long-term stability and low-frequency noise. RESULTS: The best results were obtained with the reusable sintered Ag|AgCl electrodes. The six disposable Ag|AgCl electrode models also proved to have appropriate electrical properties. Other types of reusable electrodes suffered from diverse degrees of polarization, baseline drift, low-frequency noise, high resistance, and changes in properties due to wear and tear. Seven out of nine gels or pastes contained a significant amount of chloride, which is a prerequisite for DC stability of Ag|AgCl electrodes, whereas the absolute concentration of chloride had little effect. CONCLUSIONS: Direct current (DC) coupled recording of EEG is critically dependent on the choice of electrode and gel. SIGNIFICANCE: Our results provide rigorous criteria for choosing DC-stable electrodes and gels for DC-coupled or long time-constant AC-coupled recordings of slow EEG potentials.
OBJECTIVE: To test the applicability of different types of commercially available electrodes and electrode gels or pastes for recording of slow EEG potentials. METHODS: Experiments were carried out on six types of reusable electrodes (silver, tin and gold cup electrodes, sintered silver-silver chloride (Ag|AgCl), platinum, stainless steel), six disposable Ag|AgCl electrode models, and nine gels or pastes. We studied the parameters, which are critical in slow-potential recording, such as polarization, initial and long-term stability and low-frequency noise. RESULTS: The best results were obtained with the reusable sintered Ag|AgCl electrodes. The six disposable Ag|AgCl electrode models also proved to have appropriate electrical properties. Other types of reusable electrodes suffered from diverse degrees of polarization, baseline drift, low-frequency noise, high resistance, and changes in properties due to wear and tear. Seven out of nine gels or pastes contained a significant amount of chloride, which is a prerequisite for DC stability of Ag|AgCl electrodes, whereas the absolute concentration of chloride had little effect. CONCLUSIONS: Direct current (DC) coupled recording of EEG is critically dependent on the choice of electrode and gel. SIGNIFICANCE: Our results provide rigorous criteria for choosing DC-stable electrodes and gels for DC-coupled or long time-constant AC-coupled recordings of slow EEG potentials.
Authors: Ana I Oliveira-Ferreira; Denny Milakara; Mesbah Alam; Devi Jorks; Sebastian Major; Jed A Hartings; Janos Lückl; Peter Martus; Rudolf Graf; Christian Dohmen; Georg Bohner; Johannes Woitzik; Jens P Dreier Journal: J Cereb Blood Flow Metab Date: 2010-03-24 Impact factor: 6.200
Authors: Joshua K Grooms; Garth J Thompson; Wen-Ju Pan; Jacob Billings; Eric H Schumacher; Charles M Epstein; Shella D Keilholz Journal: Brain Connect Date: 2017-06
Authors: Li Jiang; Yadong Ji; Pamela J Voulalas; Michael Keaser; Su Xu; Rao P Gullapalli; Joel Greenspan; Radi Masri Journal: Brain Stimul Date: 2013-12-27 Impact factor: 8.955
Authors: A J Woods; A Antal; M Bikson; P S Boggio; A R Brunoni; P Celnik; L G Cohen; F Fregni; C S Herrmann; E S Kappenman; H Knotkova; D Liebetanz; C Miniussi; P C Miranda; W Paulus; A Priori; D Reato; C Stagg; N Wenderoth; M A Nitsche Journal: Clin Neurophysiol Date: 2015-11-22 Impact factor: 3.708