Literature DB >> 15590515

Respect: or, how respect for persons became respect for autonomy.

M Therese Lysaught1.   

Abstract

This article provides an intellectual archeology of how the term "respect" has functioned in the field of bioethics. I argue that over time the function of the term has shifted, with a significant turning point occurring in 1979. Prior to 1979, the term "respect" connoted primarily the notion of "respect for persons" which functioned as an umbrella which conferred protection to autonomous persons and those with compromised autonomy. But in 1979, with the First Edition of Principles of Biomedical Ethics by Beauchamp and Childress, and the report of the Ethical Advisory Board (EAB) of the (then) Department of Health, Education, and Welfare entitled Research on In Vitro Fertilization, usage shifts from "respect for persons" to "respect for autonomy." Two results: 1) those with compromised autonomy are no longer protected by the canons of "respect" but rather the less overriding canons of beneficence; and 2) the term "respect" functions increasingly as a rhetorical device in public bioethics discourse.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Analytical Approach; Belmont Report; Bioethics and Professional Ethics; Ethics Advisory Board; National Bioethics Advisory Commission; Principles of Biomedical Ethics (Beauchamp, T.L.; Childress, J.F.)

Mesh:

Year:  2004        PMID: 15590515     DOI: 10.1080/03605310490883028

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Med Philos        ISSN: 0360-5310


  16 in total

1.  Understanding respect: learning from patients.

Authors:  N W Dickert; N E Kass
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2009-07       Impact factor: 2.903

2.  Do patients treated with dignity report higher satisfaction, adherence, and receipt of preventive care?

Authors:  Mary Catherine Beach; Jeremy Sugarman; Rachel L Johnson; Jose J Arbelaez; Patrick S Duggan; Lisa A Cooper
Journal:  Ann Fam Med       Date:  2005 Jul-Aug       Impact factor: 5.166

3.  The Rhetoric of the 'Passive Patient' in Indian Medical Negligence Cases.

Authors:  Supriya Subramani
Journal:  Asian Bioeth Rev       Date:  2019-12-04

4.  The history of autonomy in medicine from antiquity to principlism.

Authors:  Toni C Saad
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2018-03

5.  Supported Decision Making With People at the Margins of Autonomy.

Authors:  Andrew Peterson; Jason Karlawish; Emily Largent
Journal:  Am J Bioeth       Date:  2020-12-29       Impact factor: 11.229

6.  A Genealogy of Autonomy: Freedom, Paternalism, and the Future of the Doctor-Patient Relationship.

Authors:  Quentin I T Genuis
Journal:  J Med Philos       Date:  2021-06-09

7.  Demonstrating 'respect for persons' in clinical research: findings from qualitative interviews with diverse genomics research participants.

Authors:  Stephanie A Kraft; Erin Rothwell; Seema K Shah; Devan M Duenas; Hannah Lewis; Kristin Muessig; Douglas J Opel; Katrina A B Goddard; Benjamin S Wilfond
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2020-10-06       Impact factor: 2.903

8.  POLST Signature Requirements: Responding With Compassion While Ensuring Informed Consent.

Authors:  Robert Macauley; Susan Tolle
Journal:  Am J Hosp Palliat Care       Date:  2020-09-01       Impact factor: 2.500

9.  An ethical façade? Medical students' miscomprehensions of substituted judgment.

Authors:  Farr A Curlin; Ryan E Lawrence; Julie Fredrickson
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2009-02-04       Impact factor: 3.240

10.  What does 'respect' mean? Exploring the moral obligation of health professionals to respect patients.

Authors:  Mary Catherine Beach; Patrick S Duggan; Christine K Cassel; Gail Geller
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2007-05       Impact factor: 5.128

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.