Drew A Bednar1. 1. Division of Orthopedic Surgery, Department of Surgery, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont. spinopod@allstream.net
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of soft, semirigid and hard cervical collars to immobilize the neck in a destabilized cadaver model. DESIGN: This is a laboratory experiment. SETTING: The anatomy research lab of McMaster University. PATIENTS: None. Fresh cadavers from elderly patients suffering terminal medical illness and free of cervical structural disease were studied. INTERVENTIONS: Destabilizing discoligamentous lesions of the neck were created in the cadavers. Radiographs were taken in maximum displacement in the prone, decubitus and side-bending positions, first unsupported and then with soft, semirigid and hard collars applied. Displacements in angulation and translation were measured from the radiographs. OUTCOME MEASURES: Radiographic displacement under gravity load. RESULTS: In all cases there was no effective limitation of pathological displacement, and in many cases displacement was increased after collar application. CONCLUSIONS: Cervical collars do not effectively support the unstable neck, and may be ineffective in preventing pathological displacements.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of soft, semirigid and hard cervical collars to immobilize the neck in a destabilized cadaver model. DESIGN: This is a laboratory experiment. SETTING: The anatomy research lab of McMaster University. PATIENTS: None. Fresh cadavers from elderly patients suffering terminal medical illness and free of cervical structural disease were studied. INTERVENTIONS: Destabilizing discoligamentous lesions of the neck were created in the cadavers. Radiographs were taken in maximum displacement in the prone, decubitus and side-bending positions, first unsupported and then with soft, semirigid and hard collars applied. Displacements in angulation and translation were measured from the radiographs. OUTCOME MEASURES: Radiographic displacement under gravity load. RESULTS: In all cases there was no effective limitation of pathological displacement, and in many cases displacement was increased after collar application. CONCLUSIONS: Cervical collars do not effectively support the unstable neck, and may be ineffective in preventing pathological displacements.
Authors: L F Marshall; S Knowlton; S R Garfin; M R Klauber; H M Eisenberg; D Kopaniky; M E Miner; K Tabbador; G L Clifton Journal: J Neurosurg Date: 1987-03 Impact factor: 5.115
Authors: Erik E Swartz; Barry P Boden; Ronald W Courson; Laura C Decoster; MaryBeth Horodyski; Susan A Norkus; Robb S Rehberg; Kevin N Waninger Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2009 May-Jun Impact factor: 2.860