BACKGROUND: Recurrence of trichiasis following surgery remains unacceptably high, regardless of the surgical procedure. Few prospective studies of sufficient size are available to assess the rate of recurrence and the factors contributing to recurrence. A prospective study of the modified Cuenod Nataf surgical procedure was conducted in Vietnam to determine recurrence and co-factors. METHODS: The prospective study of Cuenod Nataf surgery for trachomatous trichiasis took place in four districts of Vietnam. All patients from identified villages who had surgery were followed for a period of 1 year. 10 Surgeons using standard techniques and recording procedures carried out the surgery. The presence of an eyelash touching the eyeball in the operated eye was considered as recurrence. Information on all subjects was recorded preoperatively, intraoperatively, and postoperatively. An independent examiner recorded postoperative information. Relative risks were calculated to assess the contribution of various risk factors to recurrence (by eye and by person). Cox proportional hazards modelling was used to assess the independent contribution of relevant factors to the outcome. RESULTS: 471 individuals had trichiasis surgery; 463 were followed for a period of 1 year. Overall, the recurrence rate was 10.8% (95% CI 8.0 to 13.6). Among people having surgery recurrence (one or both eyes) was most common in the most elderly (relative risk (RR) 2.49) and among those with a history of previous surgery (RR = 2.49). Cox proportional hazards analysis (by eye) revealed that visual acuity, conjunctival scarring, and suture adjustment were associated with recurrence at 1 year. CONCLUSION: The Cuenod Nataf procedure, which is well accepted in the community and by eye care providers in Vietnam, has an acceptable 1 year success rate. Individuals with severe conjunctival scarring have the highest rate of recurrence suggesting that other surgical approaches are needed to manage these patients or that these patients need to be educated regarding the risk of recurrence. Active follow up of these patients would be warranted. The association with suture adjustment requires further investigation.
BACKGROUND: Recurrence of trichiasis following surgery remains unacceptably high, regardless of the surgical procedure. Few prospective studies of sufficient size are available to assess the rate of recurrence and the factors contributing to recurrence. A prospective study of the modified Cuenod Nataf surgical procedure was conducted in Vietnam to determine recurrence and co-factors. METHODS: The prospective study of Cuenod Nataf surgery for trachomatous trichiasis took place in four districts of Vietnam. All patients from identified villages who had surgery were followed for a period of 1 year. 10 Surgeons using standard techniques and recording procedures carried out the surgery. The presence of an eyelash touching the eyeball in the operated eye was considered as recurrence. Information on all subjects was recorded preoperatively, intraoperatively, and postoperatively. An independent examiner recorded postoperative information. Relative risks were calculated to assess the contribution of various risk factors to recurrence (by eye and by person). Cox proportional hazards modelling was used to assess the independent contribution of relevant factors to the outcome. RESULTS: 471 individuals had trichiasis surgery; 463 were followed for a period of 1 year. Overall, the recurrence rate was 10.8% (95% CI 8.0 to 13.6). Among people having surgery recurrence (one or both eyes) was most common in the most elderly (relative risk (RR) 2.49) and among those with a history of previous surgery (RR = 2.49). Cox proportional hazards analysis (by eye) revealed that visual acuity, conjunctival scarring, and suture adjustment were associated with recurrence at 1 year. CONCLUSION: The Cuenod Nataf procedure, which is well accepted in the community and by eye care providers in Vietnam, has an acceptable 1 year success rate. Individuals with severe conjunctival scarring have the highest rate of recurrence suggesting that other surgical approaches are needed to manage these patients or that these patients need to be educated regarding the risk of recurrence. Active follow up of these patients would be warranted. The association with suture adjustment requires further investigation.
Authors: Saul N Rajak; Pateh Makalo; Ansumana Sillah; Martin J Holland; David C W Mabey; Robin L Bailey; Matthew J Burton Journal: Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci Date: 2010-05-26 Impact factor: 4.799
Authors: Emily W Gower; Shannath L Merbs; Beatriz E Munoz; Amir Bedri Kello; Wondu Alemayehu; Alemush Imeru; Sheila K West Journal: Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci Date: 2011-04-25 Impact factor: 4.799
Authors: Katherine Pearson; Dereje Habte; Mulat Zerihun; Jonathan D King; Teshome Gebre; Paul M Emerson; Mark H Reacher; Jeremiah M Ngondi Journal: Ethiop J Health Sci Date: 2013-07