David W Easter1, Wayne Beach. 1. Department of Surgery, University of California San Diego School of Medicine, La Jolla, 92093, USA. deaster@ucsd.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Core competencies in surgical education and clinical care rely on effective patient-physician communication. We aim to develop quantitative and empirical tools for understanding critical communication tasks during patient interviews. METHODS: Residents in surgical training and attending physicians were separately video recorded during stressful, first visit oncology patient interview sessions. Taped sessions (n = 16) were analyzed in detail to identify and label patient-initiated actions (PIAs), or "empathic opportunities," that call for recognition or action from the caregiver. Doctor-responsive actions (DRAs) were labeled as matching to, or missing from, each empathic opportunity. Missed empathic opportunities occurred when a PIA did not have an associated DRA. Presession and postsession surveys queried the patient's perception of how well their health-care needs were met. RESULTS: Resident trainees and attending physicians missed 70% of 160 clearly identified empathic opportunities. There was no clear association with the level of physician training. This pilot study did not have enough power to discern differences in patient satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: Physicians are often not very attentive to empathic opportunities offered by patients. Individual feedback and training regarding empathic opportunities in recorded patient communication encounters may improve resident and physician core competencies. These improvements may affect patient satisfaction related to these encounters.
OBJECTIVE: Core competencies in surgical education and clinical care rely on effective patient-physician communication. We aim to develop quantitative and empirical tools for understanding critical communication tasks during patient interviews. METHODS: Residents in surgical training and attending physicians were separately video recorded during stressful, first visit oncology patient interview sessions. Taped sessions (n = 16) were analyzed in detail to identify and label patient-initiated actions (PIAs), or "empathic opportunities," that call for recognition or action from the caregiver. Doctor-responsive actions (DRAs) were labeled as matching to, or missing from, each empathic opportunity. Missed empathic opportunities occurred when a PIA did not have an associated DRA. Presession and postsession surveys queried the patient's perception of how well their health-care needs were met. RESULTS: Resident trainees and attending physicians missed 70% of 160 clearly identified empathic opportunities. There was no clear association with the level of physician training. This pilot study did not have enough power to discern differences in patient satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: Physicians are often not very attentive to empathic opportunities offered by patients. Individual feedback and training regarding empathic opportunities in recorded patient communication encounters may improve resident and physician core competencies. These improvements may affect patient satisfaction related to these encounters.
Authors: Elaine Wittenberg-Lyles; Parker Oliver Debra; George Demiris; Anna Rankin; Sara Shaunfield; Robin L Kruse Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2012-05-01
Authors: Maria Cherba; Boris H J M Brummans; Michael P Hier; Lauriane Giguère; Gabrielle Chartier; Hannah Jacobs; Véronique-Isabelle Forest; Alex Mlynarek; Khalil Sultanem; Melissa Henry Journal: Curr Oncol Date: 2022-05-05 Impact factor: 3.109
Authors: Shane Sinclair; Jill M Norris; Shelagh J McConnell; Harvey Max Chochinov; Thomas F Hack; Neil A Hagen; Susan McClement; Shelley Raffin Bouchal Journal: BMC Palliat Care Date: 2016-01-19 Impact factor: 3.234
Authors: Shane Sinclair; Mia-Bernadine Torres; Shelley Raffin-Bouchal; Thomas F Hack; Susan McClement; Neil A Hagen; Harvey M Chochinov Journal: BMC Med Educ Date: 2016-07-11 Impact factor: 2.463
Authors: Timothy J Williamson; Jamie S Ostroff; Chloé M Martin; Smita C Banerjee; Carma L Bylund; Heidi A Hamann; Megan Johnson Shen Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2020-08-11