BACKGROUND: Slowed heart rate recovery (HRR) of less than 12 beats per minute in the first minute after an exercise stress test has been suggested as a useful addition to the criteria currently used to assess exercise stress test results. Although HRR has been tested in large populations, the short-term test-retest stability (reproducibility) of abnormal HRR for an individual has not been assessed. METHODS: The study was a retrospective comparison of medical record information using a community-practice-based sample of 90 patients undergoing 2 exercise stress tests separated by 18 weeks or less. Concordance of abnormal HRR results on the first and second stress tests were assessed for individual patients using definitions of abnormal HRR from the medical literature. RESULTS: Individual patient's HRR was markedly variable from the first to second stress test. In this sample, no definition of abnormal HRR provided more than 55% concordance between results from the first and second stress tests. CONCLUSION: These preliminary data suggest that HRR appears to have limited short-term test-retest stability or reproducibility and therefore might not be a reliable addition to current results of exercise stress tests.
BACKGROUND: Slowed heart rate recovery (HRR) of less than 12 beats per minute in the first minute after an exercise stress test has been suggested as a useful addition to the criteria currently used to assess exercise stress test results. Although HRR has been tested in large populations, the short-term test-retest stability (reproducibility) of abnormal HRR for an individual has not been assessed. METHODS: The study was a retrospective comparison of medical record information using a community-practice-based sample of 90 patients undergoing 2 exercise stress tests separated by 18 weeks or less. Concordance of abnormal HRR results on the first and second stress tests were assessed for individual patients using definitions of abnormal HRR from the medical literature. RESULTS: Individual patient's HRR was markedly variable from the first to second stress test. In this sample, no definition of abnormal HRR provided more than 55% concordance between results from the first and second stress tests. CONCLUSION: These preliminary data suggest that HRR appears to have limited short-term test-retest stability or reproducibility and therefore might not be a reliable addition to current results of exercise stress tests.
Authors: Erol Tulumen; Indira Khalilayeva; Kudret Aytemir; F E S C Ergun Baris Kaya; Onur Sinan Deveci; Hakan Aksoy; Ugur Kocabas; Sercan Okutucu; Lale Tokgozoglu; Giray Kabakci; Hilmi Ozkutlu; Ali Oto Journal: Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol Date: 2011-10 Impact factor: 1.468
Authors: Christian Spies; Christian Otte; Alka Kanaya; Sharon S Pipkin; Nelson B Schiller; Mary A Whooley Journal: Am J Cardiol Date: 2005-05-15 Impact factor: 2.778
Authors: Olugbenga O Abiodun; Michael O Balogun; Anthony O Akintomide; Rasaaq A Adebayo; Olufemi E Ajayi; Suraj A Ogunyemi; Valentine N Amadi; Victor O Adeyeye Journal: Integr Blood Press Control Date: 2015-08-11