Comparative study of the phototoxicity of two chrolin type photosensitizers, ATX-S10(Na) and verteporfin, on vascular endothelial and retinal pigment epithelial cells.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: To compare the phototoxicity in photodynamic therapy (PDT) of ATX-S10(Na) and Verteporfin on human microvascular endothelial cells (HMVEC), vascular endothelial cells of monkey choroid and retina (CRVEC), and human retinal pigment epithelial cells (HRPE). STUDY DESIGN/
MATERIALS AND METHODS: PDT was performed in two different ways. In short dye-exposure PDT, HMVEC and CRVEC were exposed to each photosensitizer for 5 minutes followed by laser irradiation of 670 nm wavelength for ATX-S10(Na) or 689 nm for Verteporfin without washing out the photosensitizer in the medium. In long dye-exposure PDT, the cells were exposed to photosensitizers for times ranging from 5 minutes to 2 hours, washed out the photosensitizers, followed by laser irradiation in a fresh medium. PDT was performed on HRPE with PDT doses that resulted in damaging 90% of the HMVEC (ED(90)). Phototoxicity was determined by MTS Assay 1 day after PDT.
RESULTS: The degree of phototoxicity depended on the dye concentration, laser dose, and dye exposure time. In short dye-exposure PDT on HMVEC with a laser dose of 50 J/cm(2), the ED(90) was 6.3 microg/ml of ATX-S10(Na) and 0.04 microg/ml of Verteporfin, while in long dye-exposure PDT the ED(90) was 50.0 microg/ml of ATX-S10(Na) and 0.04 microg/ml of Verteporfin when the medium was supplemented with 5% fetal calf serum. The phototoxic rate on HMVEC was higher when the medium contained 5% as contrasted with 10% of serum. In short dye-exposure PDT, the ED(90) of CRVEC was 100 microg/ml of ATX-S10(Na) and an irradiance of 100 J/cm(2), and 0.08 microg/ml of Verteporfin and an irradiance of 100 J/cm(2) when the medium was supplemented with 10% serum. With some doses of short dye-exposure PDT, the ATX-S10(Na) achieved higher phototoxic rates on HMVEC and CRVEC than on the HRPE. However, long dye-exposure PDT with ATX-S10(Na) and short and long dye-exposure PDT with Vereteporfin failed to obtain higher phototoxic rates on HMVEC and CRVEC than on HRPE.
CONCLUSIONS: Verteporfin had a higher phototoxicity than ATX-S10(Na) on HMVEC and CRVEC. The CRVEC resisted more than HMVEC following PDT with both photosensitizers. In short dye-exposure PDT, ATX-S10(Na) had a more selective phototoxicity on HMVEC and CRVEC than on HRPE. Copyright 2004 Wiley-Liss, Inc.