Combinatorial minimization and secondary structure determination of a nucleotide synthase ribozyme.

We previously isolated from random sequences ribozymes able to form a glycosidic linkage between a ribose sugar and 4-thiouracil in a reaction that mimics protein-catalyzed nucleotide synthesis. Here we report on two serial in vitro selection experiments that defined the core motif of one of the nucleotide synthase ribozymes and provided improved versions of this ribozyme. The first selection experiment started from a degenerate sequence pool based on the previously isolated sequence and used a selection-amplification protocol that allowed the sequence requirements at the 3' terminus of the ribozyme to be interrogated. Comparing the active sequences identified in this experiment revealed the complicated secondary structure of the nucleotide synthase ribozyme. A second selection was then performed to remove nonessential sequence from the ribozyme. This selection started with a pool with variation introduced in both the sequence and the length of the nonconserved loops and joining regions. This pool was generated using a partial reblocking/deblocking strategy on a DNA synthesizer, allowing the combinatorial synthesis of both point deletions and point substitutions. The consensus ribozyme motif that emerged was an approximately 71 nt pseudoknot structure with five stems and two important joining segments. Comparative sequence analysis and a cross-linking experiment point to the probable location of nucleotide synthesis. The prototype isolate from the second selection was nearly 35 times more efficient than the initial isolate and at least 10(8) times more efficient than an upper limit of an as-yet undetectable uncatalyzed reaction, supporting the idea that RNA-catalyzed nucleotide synthesis might have been important in an RNA world.