M Galli1, V De Santis, L Tafuro. 1. Orthopaedic Department, Catholic University, Rome, Italy. dottorgalli@yahoo.it
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess the inter-observer reliability and intra-observer reproducibility of the Ahlbäck radiographic classification for knee osteoarthritis (OA). DESIGN: Ninety-six knee radiographs of patients with clinical signs of arthritis were evaluated and classified into five grades of Ahlbäck classification by three observers with different experience. The evaluation was repeated after 1 month. The inter- and intra-rater agreements were assessed by statistical analysis (k and k(w)coefficients). RESULTS: The inter-observer agreement was statistically significant, but with low or medium values of the coefficients. The intra-rater agreement was less significant than the inter-rater. Inter- and intra-rater agreement coefficients decreased when the cases of stage V arthritis were excluded from the analysis. The evaluations were influenced by the age and working experiences of each observer. CONCLUSIONS: The authors stress that the Ahlbäck classification, as routinely applied, should not be used in orthopaedic surgery without the support of clinical and/or arthroscopic examinations, because of its poor reliability.
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess the inter-observer reliability and intra-observer reproducibility of the Ahlbäck radiographic classification for knee osteoarthritis (OA). DESIGN: Ninety-six knee radiographs of patients with clinical signs of arthritis were evaluated and classified into five grades of Ahlbäck classification by three observers with different experience. The evaluation was repeated after 1 month. The inter- and intra-rater agreements were assessed by statistical analysis (k and k(w)coefficients). RESULTS: The inter-observer agreement was statistically significant, but with low or medium values of the coefficients. The intra-rater agreement was less significant than the inter-rater. Inter- and intra-rater agreement coefficients decreased when the cases of stage V arthritis were excluded from the analysis. The evaluations were influenced by the age and working experiences of each observer. CONCLUSIONS: The authors stress that the Ahlbäck classification, as routinely applied, should not be used in orthopaedic surgery without the support of clinical and/or arthroscopic examinations, because of its poor reliability.
Authors: Caroline B Boulocher; Eric R Viguier; Rodrigo Da Rocha Cararo; Didier J Fau; Fabien Arnault; Fabien Collard; Pierre A Maitre; Olivier Roualdes; Marie-Eve Duclos; Eric P Vignon; Thierry W Roger Journal: BMC Med Imaging Date: 2010-01-20 Impact factor: 1.930
Authors: N A Segal; M T Murphy; B M Everist; K D Brown; J He; J A Lynch; M C Nevitt Journal: Osteoarthritis Cartilage Date: 2021-07-29 Impact factor: 6.576