Subcortical aphasia: three different language disorder syndromes?

The study analyses clinical presentation of language functions of 32 patients with subcortical aphasia induced by stroke. The patients have been divided into three groups according to neuroanatomic localization of the lesion, defined by CT and MRI examination (striato-capsular aphasia, aphasia associated with white matter paraventricular lesions and thalamic aphasia). The following batteries and tests were used: the neurologic examination, CT scan, MRI, Doppler ultrasound, Mini Mental State Examination, Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination (BDAE), Boston Naming Test (BNT), Token Test and Verbal Fluency Test. Clinical presentation of subcortical aphasias is characterized with preserved repetition, however, some groups differ by certain specific features of language impairment. Striato-capsular aphasia and aphasia associated with white matter paraventricular lesions are characterized with lack of speech fluency, occurrence of literary paraphasias, mainly preserved comprehension and naming. Thalamic aphasia, however, is characterized with fluent output, impaired comprehension and naming with predominant verbal paraphasias. The specific features of language impairment suggest that subcortical structures contribute to language organization. Considering the results of language tests we presume that the most prominent feature in striato-capsular aphasia is phonetic impairment of language, opposite to thalamic aphasia where lexical-sematic processing seems to be affected.