OBJECTIVE: To study the sites of positive surgical margins after radical prostatectomy according to the technique used: retropubic, perineal or laparoscopic. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 538 radical prostatectomies were performed between 1988 and 2001: 184 via a retropubic approach, 119 via a perineal approach and 235 by laparoscopy. Clinical examination, PSA assay (Hybritech, Normal < 4 ng/ml) and transrectal biopsies were performed in all patients. The radical prostatectomy specimen was examined by the same pathologist according to the Stanford protocol. The frequency and site of positive surgical margins were studied as a function of pathological stage. RESULTS: The positive surgical margins rate was 32%, 18.5% and 26.4% for the retropubic, perineal and laparoscopic techniques, respectively. The most frequent site of positive surgical margins was the apex for retropubic (41.1%) and perineal (41.6%) prostatectomy and the posterolateral part of the prostate for laparoscopic prostatectomy (41.9%). The most frequent site of positive surgical margins in pT2 tumours was the apex for the retropubic approach (50%), the base of the prostate (bladder neck) for the perineal approach (41.6%) and the apex and posterolateral part of the prostate for the laparoscopic approach (44.4% and 41.6%). CONCLUSION: Each radical prostatectomy technique corresponds to a preferential site of positive surgical margins: the apex for the retropubic approach, the bladder neck for the perineal approach and the posterolateral part of the prostate for the laparoscopic approach.
OBJECTIVE: To study the sites of positive surgical margins after radical prostatectomy according to the technique used: retropubic, perineal or laparoscopic. MATERIAL AND METHODS: 538 radical prostatectomies were performed between 1988 and 2001: 184 via a retropubic approach, 119 via a perineal approach and 235 by laparoscopy. Clinical examination, PSA assay (Hybritech, Normal < 4 ng/ml) and transrectal biopsies were performed in all patients. The radical prostatectomy specimen was examined by the same pathologist according to the Stanford protocol. The frequency and site of positive surgical margins were studied as a function of pathological stage. RESULTS: The positive surgical margins rate was 32%, 18.5% and 26.4% for the retropubic, perineal and laparoscopic techniques, respectively. The most frequent site of positive surgical margins was the apex for retropubic (41.1%) and perineal (41.6%) prostatectomy and the posterolateral part of the prostate for laparoscopic prostatectomy (41.9%). The most frequent site of positive surgical margins in pT2 tumours was the apex for the retropubic approach (50%), the base of the prostate (bladder neck) for the perineal approach (41.6%) and the apex and posterolateral part of the prostate for the laparoscopic approach (44.4% and 41.6%). CONCLUSION: Each radical prostatectomy technique corresponds to a preferential site of positive surgical margins: the apex for the retropubic approach, the bladder neck for the perineal approach and the posterolateral part of the prostate for the laparoscopic approach.
Authors: Athanase Billis; Isabela C Watanabe; Matheus V Costa; Gilliat H Telles; Luis A Magna Journal: Int Urol Nephrol Date: 2007-06-30 Impact factor: 2.370