PURPOSE: To examine the long-term psychosocial outcomes of a consecutive series of patients who underwent anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) compared with medically managed patients. This study focused primarily on actual long-term changes (mean, 5 years) in life performance. There are relatively few long-term controlled studies of actual lifetime performance changes. METHODS: The sample consisted of 61 adults who underwent ATL and 23 individuals who were evaluated for surgery but did not proceed to surgery and continued to receive medical management. Participants were interviewed 2-9 years after surgery. A structured clinical interview and review of medical records was conducted to obtain information regarding seizure frequency and psychosocial status, focusing on employment, education, driving status, financial assistance, and independent living. In addition, two questions regarding quality of life were included. Seizure frequency was evaluated for the year before the interview. RESULTS: Significant differences in psychosocial outcome were found between the surgery group and medical management group. Favorable psychosocial outcomes were more common among those who had surgery (46 vs. 4%). Results indicated that 68% of the surgery group exhibited improved psychosocial status compared with 5% of the medical management group. Individuals who had surgery were more likely to be driving, working full-time, living independently, and being financially independent. Remaining seizure free was not a prerequisite for improvements in psychosocial outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with medical management, surgery has a significant positive impact on psychosocial outcomes in terms of employment, independent living, driving, and financial independence. Additionally, a person does not necessarily have to be seizure free to achieve positive changes in psychosocial outcomes.
PURPOSE: To examine the long-term psychosocial outcomes of a consecutive series of patients who underwent anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) compared with medically managed patients. This study focused primarily on actual long-term changes (mean, 5 years) in life performance. There are relatively few long-term controlled studies of actual lifetime performance changes. METHODS: The sample consisted of 61 adults who underwent ATL and 23 individuals who were evaluated for surgery but did not proceed to surgery and continued to receive medical management. Participants were interviewed 2-9 years after surgery. A structured clinical interview and review of medical records was conducted to obtain information regarding seizure frequency and psychosocial status, focusing on employment, education, driving status, financial assistance, and independent living. In addition, two questions regarding quality of life were included. Seizure frequency was evaluated for the year before the interview. RESULTS: Significant differences in psychosocial outcome were found between the surgery group and medical management group. Favorable psychosocial outcomes were more common among those who had surgery (46 vs. 4%). Results indicated that 68% of the surgery group exhibited improved psychosocial status compared with 5% of the medical management group. Individuals who had surgery were more likely to be driving, working full-time, living independently, and being financially independent. Remaining seizure free was not a prerequisite for improvements in psychosocial outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with medical management, surgery has a significant positive impact on psychosocial outcomes in terms of employment, independent living, driving, and financial independence. Additionally, a person does not necessarily have to be seizure free to achieve positive changes in psychosocial outcomes.
Authors: Brigid E Prayson; Darlene P Floden; Lisa Ferguson; Kevin H Kim; Lara Jehi; Robyn M Busch Journal: Epilepsy Behav Date: 2017-01-28 Impact factor: 2.937
Authors: T Kral; M von Lehe; M Podlogar; H Clusmann; P Süssmann; M Kurthen; A Becker; H Urbach; J Schramm Journal: J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Date: 2007-02-07 Impact factor: 10.154
Authors: Christianne N Heck; David King-Stephens; Andrew D Massey; Dileep R Nair; Barbara C Jobst; Gregory L Barkley; Vicenta Salanova; Andrew J Cole; Michael C Smith; Ryder P Gwinn; Christopher Skidmore; Paul C Van Ness; Gregory K Bergey; Yong D Park; Ian Miller; Eric Geller; Paul A Rutecki; Richard Zimmerman; David C Spencer; Alica Goldman; Jonathan C Edwards; James W Leiphart; Robert E Wharen; James Fessler; Nathan B Fountain; Gregory A Worrell; Robert E Gross; Stephan Eisenschenk; Robert B Duckrow; Lawrence J Hirsch; Carl Bazil; Cormac A O'Donovan; Felice T Sun; Tracy A Courtney; Cairn G Seale; Martha J Morrell Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2014-02-22 Impact factor: 5.864