F A Chervenak1, L B McCullough, Z Rosenwaks. 1. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, New York Presbyterian Hospital, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, New York 10021, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE: We propose an ethically justified policy for the number of embryos to transfer in an in vitro fertilization (IVF), by considering fourfactors: medical outcomes, patient's preferences, costs, and market forces of providers. METHODS: We develop an ethical framework that incorporates three ethical principles: beneficence, respect for autonomy, and justice; and three professional virtues: integrity, compassion, and self-sacrifice. RESULTS: This ethical framework calls for an informed consent process for IVF that provides: information about medical outcomes; information about the risks of multiple gestation; the opportunity to weigh the goal of pregnancy and live birth against the medical and moral risks of multiple gestation; evidence-based recommendations; protection of the woman from potentially coercive influences; and discussion of living with infertility and going to better centers. CONCLUSION: The number of embryos to be transferred in IVF should mainly be a function of the pregnant women's informed decision. Limiting the number of transferred embryos to two in all cases is not ethically justified at this time.
PURPOSE: We propose an ethically justified policy for the number of embryos to transfer in an in vitro fertilization (IVF), by considering fourfactors: medical outcomes, patient's preferences, costs, and market forces of providers. METHODS: We develop an ethical framework that incorporates three ethical principles: beneficence, respect for autonomy, and justice; and three professional virtues: integrity, compassion, and self-sacrifice. RESULTS: This ethical framework calls for an informed consent process for IVF that provides: information about medical outcomes; information about the risks of multiple gestation; the opportunity to weigh the goal of pregnancy and live birth against the medical and moral risks of multiple gestation; evidence-based recommendations; protection of the woman from potentially coercive influences; and discussion of living with infertility and going to better centers. CONCLUSION: The number of embryos to be transferred in IVF should mainly be a function of the pregnant women's informed decision. Limiting the number of transferred embryos to two in all cases is not ethically justified at this time.