Biomechanical comparison of ankle arthrodesis techniques: crossed screws vs. blade plate.

Many different techniques for ankle arthrodesis have been described. Experience at our institution with crossed screws internal fixation has not met the 90+% union rate reported in the literature. A compression blade plate is one technique for ankle arthrodesis which has not been evaluated biomechanically. A biomechanical study comparing two groups of sawbone ankle fusion constructs fixed with crossed screws and compression blade plates was performed in order to evaluate the stiffness and rigidity of these two arthrodesis techniques. The crossed screws construct demonstrated superior stiffness during dorsiflexion (p < 0.001) and valgus (p < 0.001) loading. The two constructs were found to have equal strength in resisting plantarflexion, varus and torsional loads although there was a trend for greater resistance by the crossed screws construct. These findings lend biomechanical support to the use of crossed screws for tibiotalar arthrodesis.