J J Gary1, E F Huget, L D Powell. 1. College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee, Memphis, Tenn 38163, USA. jgary@utmem.edu
Abstract
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Maxillofacial prostheses require frequent replacement because the elastomer and its color additives undergo changes. PURPOSE: This study attempted to determine whether predictable color changes occur when 3 pigments are individually incorporated into a specific silicone elastomer. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The materials included an RTV elastomer; 1 natural inorganic pigment, burnt sienna; and 2 synthetic organic pigments, Hansa yellow and alizarin red. Eight test groups of 10 polymerized specimens were established. Groups 1 and 2, acting as the control, involved only the elastomer. Groups 3 and 4 were composed of elastomer and burnt sienna. Groups 5 and 6 consisted of elastomer and Hansa yellow. Groups 7 and 8 comprised elastomer and alizarin red. Odd-numbered groups were assigned to a test site in Miami, Fla., whereas the even numbered groups went to Phoenix, Ariz. Specimens weathered in Miami and Phoenix received sunlight exposures of 1305.7 MJ/m2 and 1310.2 MJ/m2, respectively, over time. Before and after weathering, the L* a* b* color parameter (DeltaE*) of each specimen was determined spectrophotometrically. RESULTS: Mean color changes that occurred in Arizona were larger than those produced in Florida. Specifically, these differences ranged from 0.4 (alizarin red groups) to 2.36 units for the 2 unpigmented control groups. Other differences showed significance for the unpigmented (P=.001), burnt sienna (P=.006), and Hansa yellow groups (P=.001). CONCLUSION: Outdoor weathering tests in which documented ASTM methods were used provided a valid baseline for future research on color changes in maxillofacial prostheses.
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Maxillofacial prostheses require frequent replacement because the elastomer and its color additives undergo changes. PURPOSE: This study attempted to determine whether predictable color changes occur when 3 pigments are individually incorporated into a specific silicone elastomer. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The materials included an RTV elastomer; 1 natural inorganic pigment, burnt sienna; and 2 synthetic organic pigments, Hansa yellow and alizarin red. Eight test groups of 10 polymerized specimens were established. Groups 1 and 2, acting as the control, involved only the elastomer. Groups 3 and 4 were composed of elastomer and burnt sienna. Groups 5 and 6 consisted of elastomer and Hansa yellow. Groups 7 and 8 comprised elastomer and alizarin red. Odd-numbered groups were assigned to a test site in Miami, Fla., whereas the even numbered groups went to Phoenix, Ariz. Specimens weathered in Miami and Phoenix received sunlight exposures of 1305.7 MJ/m2 and 1310.2 MJ/m2, respectively, over time. Before and after weathering, the L* a* b* color parameter (DeltaE*) of each specimen was determined spectrophotometrically. RESULTS: Mean color changes that occurred in Arizona were larger than those produced in Florida. Specifically, these differences ranged from 0.4 (alizarin red groups) to 2.36 units for the 2 unpigmented control groups. Other differences showed significance for the unpigmented (P=.001), burnt sienna (P=.006), and Hansa yellow groups (P=.001). CONCLUSION: Outdoor weathering tests in which documented ASTM methods were used provided a valid baseline for future research on color changes in maxillofacial prostheses.