A W Bateman1, P Fonagy. 1. Halliwick Psychotherapy Unit, St Ann's Hospital, London.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Psychiatrists have been criticised for failing to develop adequate treatment for personality disorder. Psychotherapeutic treatments are promising, but their effectiveness is uncertain. AIMS: To investigate the evidence for effectiveness of psychotherapeutic treatment for personality disorder. METHOD: Systematic literature review. RESULTS: There is evidence for the effectiveness of psychotherapy for personality disorder. Problems of case identification, comorbidity, randomisation, specificity of treatment and outcome measurement are inadequately addressed. Authors mainly relied on cohort studies. Evidence neither suggests superiority of one type of therapy over another nor indicates which subgroups of patients should be offered psychotherapy as in-patient, day patient, or out-patient. CONCLUSIONS: New research strategies are needed to show that personality change is both measurable and clinically meaningful. Effectiveness studies using randomised controlled designs are required. The literature suggests that effective treatment should be long-term, integrated, theoretically coherent and focused on compliance.
BACKGROUND: Psychiatrists have been criticised for failing to develop adequate treatment for personality disorder. Psychotherapeutic treatments are promising, but their effectiveness is uncertain. AIMS: To investigate the evidence for effectiveness of psychotherapeutic treatment for personality disorder. METHOD: Systematic literature review. RESULTS: There is evidence for the effectiveness of psychotherapy for personality disorder. Problems of case identification, comorbidity, randomisation, specificity of treatment and outcome measurement are inadequately addressed. Authors mainly relied on cohort studies. Evidence neither suggests superiority of one type of therapy over another nor indicates which subgroups of patients should be offered psychotherapy as in-patient, day patient, or out-patient. CONCLUSIONS: New research strategies are needed to show that personality change is both measurable and clinically meaningful. Effectiveness studies using randomised controlled designs are required. The literature suggests that effective treatment should be long-term, integrated, theoretically coherent and focused on compliance.
Authors: Crispin Day; Jackie Briskman; Mike J Crawford; Lisa Foote; Lucy Harris; Janet Boadu; Paul McCrone; Mary McMurran; Daniel Michelson; Paul Moran; Liberty Mosse; Stephen Scott; Daniel Stahl; Paul Ramchandani; Timothy Weaver Journal: Health Technol Assess Date: 2020-03 Impact factor: 4.014