Comparison of resin and solution screening methodologies in combinatorial chemistry and the identification of a 100 nM inhibitor of trypanothione reductase.

Two identical polyamine peptide conjugate libraries were screened against the parasitic enzyme trypanothione reductase. One of these libraries was in a solution format, while the other was resin-based and was used in two resin-based screens (a diminution assay and a direct bead screening). Potent inhibitors (100 nM) of trypanothione reductase were identified both in the solution screen and in the resin-based screens when using the PEGA resin of Meldal. Resin screening of both types failed to work with TentaGel resin. Importantly there was excellent agreement between the solution and resin-based assays, suggesting both methods are reliable for the screening of combinatorial libraries.